Too futuristic or too ambiguous?
THERE are no easy answers to the question, "What is Aks all about?" The response to the film can range from "It’s a copy of Face Off’’ to "It’s a supernatural film about a spirit that dominates a human being". Or the reaction could be as vague as: "It’s about a bunch of weird people, actually we don’t know—we walked out".
A few might say that Aks is simply the representation of the two irrefutable universal truths—good and evil. Indeed, these two forces are embodied in the film by Manu Verma (Amitabh Bachchan) and Raghavan (Manoj Bajpai), respectively. The movie challenges the standard Hindi film formula of the good always triumphing over evil or good banishing evil. In fact, the film reiterates what the old Greek masters proclaimed centuries ago, that without evil, good cannot exist. The two are equally powerful forces, always in combat.
anarchy and chaos. His evil is without reason—reminding one of Iago
in Shakespeare’s Othello. His associates are the dregs of
society and he is passionate about a woman, Raveena Tandon, who doesn’t
twitch a muscle when informed that the hands that caress her are
freshly bathed in blood, who doesn’t care about any horror her lover
might perpetrate as long as he satisfies her.
Till the two forces operate independently, their identities are clear and separate. The trouble starts when both the forces fuse together. This happens when Bajpai is shot dead and his spirit enters Bachchan’s body. Hereby starts the duality which consumes Bachchan, who is involuntarily lead on to the path of evil.
Indeed, it is here that the imagery of the ‘reflection’, also denoted by the title of the movie, is used again and again. When Bachchan looks into a mirror, he sees Bajpai ‘looking back’ at him, mocking his impotence and challenging his power.
This imagery is reinforced skillfully in the scene where Bachchan is driving a car and the reflection he sees in the rear-view mirror is not his but of Bajpai. And yet again, when Bajpai in Bachchan’s body savagely rapes his wife (Nandita Das), Bachchan’s reflection looks on helplessly.
Thankfully, the film-maker (Rakesh Mehra) offers no supernatural solutions. Though Nandita Das does take Bachchan to a holy man, but all that the swami has to say is that a human being has to himself battle the forces of evil within.
Aks is probably one of the first Indian films that dares to handle a theme as difficult as this. Till the end, Mehra doesn’t take the easy way out. He does not show the evil being eradicated. Though Bachchan is finally rid of Bajpai’s ‘spirit’, the earth is not cleansed of it. Evil simply finds another body to carry out it’s chaotic designs.
Although the entire film is an allegory, it works at a more fundamental level, too, with plenty of chills and thrills and exciting song-and-dance sequences, including a strip-tense number by Tandon. The lyrics of the songs picturised on Raveena Tandon talk of darkness (Yeh Raat) or crime (Gunah kar le). The film has an international look to it, it’s pace is fastand slick. The performances are spectacular. Still, some actors are wasted in the bit roles they’re given, specifically Amol Palekar and Mohan Agashe.
However, the allegory could be too
ambiguous, and the theme, although it is rooted in the eternal conflict,
too futuristic for the Indian audiences.