The Tribune - Spectrum
 
ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK



Sunday, October 14, 2001
Books

Of love, deception and desertion
Review by Randeep Wadehra

Pavalayi
by K. Chinnappa Bharathi. Writers Workshop, Calcutta.
Pages 143. Rs 200.

Now that my ladder’s gone/ I must lie down where all the ladders start,/ In the foul rag-and-bone shop of the heart. — William Butler Yeats

LOVE has a myriad manifestations. It can render one lonely and heartbroken or make him popular and full of joy. It can be possessive or sacrificing in nature. It generates hatred in the spurned lover’s heart or it raises him to sublime heights. Cruelty comes easy to young lovers who do not care for the sensitivities of those whose heart they break while pursuing the object of their love. Yet a lover can be generous and understanding towards the rest of the humanity.

This is a love story with a difference. Set in rural Tamil Nadu, the narrative begins - not with the woman protagonist Pavalayi, after whom the novel is named, but Periannan, the golden hearted husband of Pavalayi. He is pining for her as she has deserted him after ten years of what was for him marital bliss. She leaves him for her childhood sweetheart who is now a cripple due to paralysis.

 


If it is a Tamil love story then one may be forgiven for assuming that there would be a lot of high decibel melodrama. The narrative does not get out of hand while dealing with emotional scenes, revelations and confrontations. The characters show almost realistic reactions to real life situations regarding man-woman relationship. The woman is not a whore nor is the man a raving mad villain. They are human beings caught in circumstances they are unable to understand; and they try to face up to these to the best of their abilities.

While still in her early teens, Pavalayi becomes pregnant by her cousin with whom she used to play around in the fields, while taking the cattle out for grazing. Her parents quietly get the foetus aborted and decide to marry her off to Periannan from a nearby village. Periannan was still a toddler when he lost his parents to cholera, and was brought up by his grandparents. He is the sole heir to their property - a few acres of agricultural land. He is a hard working, honest and well-built lad. Among his other virtues is his virginity that leaves him a confused man on the first night. He has absolutely no idea of his wife’s premarital affair. He loves her immensely.

It takes some time for Pavalayi to develop a soft corner for her husband - as she still pines for her first love. She bears him a son. But fate once again intervenes when Pavalayi goes to her parents’ home and meets her former lover. Dormant passions are re-ignited. One secret rendezvous leads to another. She is unaware that her husband has known her deception. However, when Pavalayi learns that her lover is struck down with paralysis and needs her help, she decides to desert her husband. She confesses her infidelity to Periannan and even tries to inflame hatred in his heart by calling him impotent.

Periannan, despite the pain, provocation and seething anger ravaging his heart, forgives her and lets her go to her lover in peace. She takes their son with her. Once when Ernest Hemingway was asked why he had deserted his wife for another woman he retorted, "Because I am a bastard". Pavalayi or Periannan shows no such nastiness. Tragedy torments their souls, and they thrash about to escape it all. Rancor is kept firmly in check even when provoked to the extreme.

The forlorn Periannan becomes an emotional and physical wreck. It is not easy for him to forget the ten blissful years he had spent with the woman he loves so passionately. It reminds one of what the English dramatist Francis Beaumont had written in "The Maid’s Tragedy": "Those have most power to hurt us that we love".

Raman, the outcaste servant of Periannan, introduces Thangammal as a farm hand. Thangammal is a widow belonging to Periannan’s caste of farmers. Soon the two begin to live together, much to the village’s chagrin. Since widow re-marriage is taboo, Thangammal commits suicide when she discovers that she is pregnant with Periannan’s child. Periannan is left alone once again. The love square ends in tragedy.

This story could be from any part of our country. The imagery and syntax is rustic. The reference to calf in a manger, the building of nest and its destruction in storm, the birds on the neem tree, the warmth and strength that the soil gives to a farmer etc. are some of the examples of universal metaphor from this narrative. Again, the rustic’s wisdom has come into play on more than one occasion - be it the quiet abortion of the unwed Pavalayi, Periannan’s immense patience with his wife’s treachery, or the need to keep on toiling against all odds. Yet it is impossible to pass value judgement on Pavalayi. It is natural for her to yearn for her first love.

What makes the reader wonder is her unconventional and bold decision to tend to her paralysed lover. She deserts her husband not out of lust, but because her lover is helpless and needs her attention. Thus there is certain non-conformist nobility in her action.

Chinnappa Bharathi, the author, is an active member of the CPM. Yet at least this novel is devoid of the usual leftist rhetoric and jargon. It reminds one of the works of such progressive writers as Munshi Premchand wherein protagonists are ordinary village folks showing extraordinary fortitude and earthy commonsense while facing the endless vicissitudes of life.

In "Pavalayi" there is a lot of philosophic dialogue too. Again, it is imbued with rural simplicity. There is something charming about this novel. It tugs at your heartstrings. I am sure it must be much better in its original version. No translation can do justice to a writer’s efforts. This is not to denigrate S. Visveswaran’s translation, though it is not exactly a professional job. I should like to put this novel in the must read category. It is much closer to the Indian reality than all the magic-prose stuff that is churned out to lure western readership.

* * *

Rabindra by Rajkumari. Writers Workshop, Calcutta. Pages 179. Rs 200.

Poetry has over the period of time lost its glamour. There was a time when it was a benchmark for achievements made or to be made by the civilised society. Poets were respected as trikaaldarshi or the ones who know the past, the present and the future. They did not merely narrate the actual happenings. As Aristotle remarks, "… poetry is something more philosophical and more worthy of serious attention than history". The poets’ works were read avidly and quoted in polite gatherings to display one’s finer tastes. Alas, all this has changed now. So has the form of poetry. The formal verse, the ballad, the sonnet et al have been replaced with free verse. This is not really bad if there is at least some sort of rhythm and imagery, or something profound.

W. H. Auden points out that a verbal art like poetry is reflective. For Mathew Arnold, "…genuine poetry is conceived and composed in the soul". In this context the book under review is the work of a person who is spiritually evolved. Even though Rajkumariwork is free verse and appears to be prose, it has a certain "soul" within that strives to reach the depths of spiritualism. She seems to endorse the philosophical canon that "nothing is real but soul or spirit; the doctrine that spirit has a real existence apart from matter; the interpretation of a varied series of abnormal phenomena as for the most part caused by spiritual beings acting upon specially sensitive persons or mediums".

In an interesting experiment, she has not given titles to her poems, and this anthology contains some poems that begin with the first line of some verse by Tagore (for example poems one to five, nine, ten and 27), and then Rajkumari goes on to finish the poems with her perception. Perhaps that is the reason she has named her collection "Rabindra". Her quest for the divine being manifests itself in almost all her compositions. The poem number 41 goes like this, "A passing thought, a few words, came - suddenly it was all swiftness of light/ In only a rhyme so much lay for me, a radiant mind/ And - God is suddenly mine, in this, this little thing."

A good read during solitude.

* * *

HIV Education and Prevention by Gracious Thomas.Shipra Publications, Delhi. Pages 252.: Rs 495.

AIDS or Acquired Immuno Deficiency Syndrome was shrouded in half-truths and misinformation for a pretty long time. There was this smug belief that this could never happen in India and only in the "promiscuous" West or the vulnerable Africa would this incurable malady strike. It was also associated with homosexuality and was considered highly contagious. Though some of the beliefs were partly true, it was wrong to presume that AIDS would never strike in India. Today the myth has exploded wshen we learn that in fact India has one of the largest numbers of people infected with the human immunodeficiency virus or HIV that causes AIDS.

Says Thomas, "According to the United Nation’s Programme on HIV/AIDS India already has more HIV infected people than any other country in the world…India has the dubious distinction of becoming the AIDS capital of the 21st century…"

The author avers that the HIV virus belongs to the family of retroviruses, which are simple microscopic organisms dependent on a host for reproduction. It is too fragile to survive for long outside the human body. Thus it is not contagious and cannot be passed from one person to another like the influenza virus. The HIV virus lacks independent metabolism and cannot grow without energy and nutrients supplied by a host cell. But despite its fragility, the HIV is "a deadly virus, which can remain in the body for several years before causing damage to the immune defence system…"

The author points out that an infected individual can lead a "perfectly normal" life for years together.

This book consists of eight chapters that deal with the detection of the virus, prevention of infection, identification of vulnerable groups of people, etc. Chapter seven is especially informative as it deals with curriculum development on AIDS, sex, and family life education. It also has a look at the existing education programme in the country. It cites IGNOU as a model in this regard.

It is a thought provoking attempt by Gracious Thomas. This volume will certainly prove invaluable to educationists as well as to those who want to have information on the deadly HIV/AIDS phenomenon.