The Tribune - Spectrum
 
ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK



Sunday, October 14, 2001
Books

Chandigarh: the creation of two cousins
Review by Sayed S. Shafi

Le Corbusier & Pierre Jeanneret: Footprints on the Sands of Indian Architecture
by Sarbjit Bahga and Surinder Bahga. Galgotia Publishing, New Delhi. Pages 367. Rs 1750.

THROUGH the ages India has had invaders and conquerors, but also scholars seeking the mysterious philosophies of a fascinating land of diverse peoples and cultures.

In the post-independence period, two of the more prominent visitors were Le Corbusier and his cousin, Pierre Jeanneret. They were invited to design a new capital for Punjab. Soon came a composite team of young Indian architects and town planners. Under the leadership of Le Corbusier it developed the Master Plan of a cciity at the foothills of the Himalayas. It is said that the outline for Chandigarh was developed within a week of the arrival of Corbusier.

Indeed, India presented him a wonderful opportunity to experiment with his otherwise thought-provoking but controversial ideas. By the 50s Corbusier’s ideas were well known, they were largely untested and a risky territory to tread. To them Corbusier was not only a non-conformist and an eccentric who could not suffer fools and was difficult to understand.

As luck would have it, no scountry in the world but India dared to give Corbusier liberty he was seeking all his life.

 


More than that, the building of Chandigarh inspired and moulded the thinking of a new generation of architects in India and the world. For young practitioners he was like a prophet whom they followed with respect and diligence traditionally reserved for gurus or ustads. Several new capital cities came later and their designs were, in some way or the other, inspired by Chandigarh. Bhubaneswar and Gandhinagar in India and Islamabad in Pakistan, the last two bear strong resemblance to the "super block" sector concept first attempted in Chandigarh. Then, came Brasila, the new capital of Brazil by Lucio Costa and Oscar Niemeyer, the later a disciple of Corbusier. Yet, none of the other cities come close to Chandigarh. It remains the boldest attempt of all and that, too. commissioned by a country struggling to rediscover itself soon after it won independence.

Besides planning the new capital city, an unexpected bonus testifying to the creative genius of Corbusier and his ever-faithful cousin, Pierre Jeanneret, came about: triggering the latent creativity of the ordinary persons and individuals unlettered and virtually unknown but working close to them. The two of them were Nek Chand and Bansi Lal. Bansi Lal was assigned to Jeanneret as Man-Friday, a multipurpose cook, bearer and valet to the great master and his gentle cousin (Jeanneret).

In fact, due to his long stay (15 years) in Chandigarh. Pierre Jeanneret endeared himself to the entire team. While Le Corbusier kept everyone in awe whenever he visited Chandigarh, Jeanneret was available to the team on a more or less informal basis. Unlike Corbusier who was arrogant, flamboyant and possessed a monumental ego with "brittle edges" in his personality that overwhelmed ordinary mortals, Pierre Jeanneret was soft-spoken and polite.

Again, Corbusier wrote a number of books and monographs (by one count 90) and in turn, many books have been written on him but hardly any book has been written on Pierre Jeanneret. Almost everyone who came in close contact with him was deeply touched by his self-effacing personality. Not only he was an architect with an uncanny talent of a form-giver, but also possessed charisma, one that would spark hidden talents and creativity. Of course Nek Chand and his Rock Garden are now well known around the world; another unknown was Dhani Ram engaged as a model maker-carpenter, he helped carving boats sketched by Jeanneret for the Sukhna Lake.

Even more interesting was the multipurpose Bansi Lal, hired as a peon and cook and bearer. He learnt to prepare French dishes, and was taught to make wines (jamun wines). In him was discovered a flair for designing dhurries and carpets with local birds and animals and floral motifs; some of those were later woven by local handlooms.

Another was Giani Rattan Singh who became a master making models from the architectural drawings and sketches of the great masters. He was the one who crafted models of the High Court building, the Secretariat and the Gandhi Bhawan in Panjab University campus.

Writing about Jeanneret, the book quotes Sneh Pandit: "In many ways Chandigarh feels the impact of Jeanneret’s work more than it does Le Corbusier’s, for it is he who helped design the mass of humbler dwellings around which the daily life of the common man is woven". Commenting on Jeanneret’s work, architectural critic Patwant Singh has remarked: "His contribution to Indian architecture can only be understood in the context of India’s architectural history.... His solutions were not impatient impositions." While, Jeanneret interpreted Corbusier’s ideas and designs and personally supervised their construction, he was simultaneously training a group of young architects who were looking up to him for guidance.

The authors state, "Pierre Jeanneret is warmly loved and admired by his Indian colleagues and assistants among whom he has automatically taken on the role of the guide and teacher." And as Patwant Singh defining Jeanneret’s personality wrote: "There was no evidence of any desire to bruise others so his own ego could be salved.... He propounded no unique philosophy, felt no need to pull people down from their pedestal, made no audacious statements to prove he was an enfant terrible of architecture. His disinterest in image-building was absolute...." He was interested only in architecture and what "Jeanneret left behind in Chandigarh is a powerful testimony to the man’s remarkable qualities."

The authors declare that Jeanneret was an embodiment of "immaculate simplicity and loved India more intensely than most Indians". He wished his ashes to be immersed in the Sukhna Lake of Chandigarh so that he would become part of his creation. To the authors goes the credit of mentioning the many buildings Jeanneret had designed in Chandigarh and elsewhere in Punjab; of these are Panjab University campus and that rare gem called Gandhi Bhavan breathing the spirit of the Mahatma’s message.

Sponsored by the Swiss Arts Council the book, "Le Corbusier & Pierre Jeanneret: Foot prints on the Sands of Indian Architecture", marks 50 years of Chandigarh. The book is a product of painstaking research undertaken by Sarbjit Bahga and Surinder Bahga, both alumni of the Chandigarh College of Architecture, a school virtually created by Le Corbusier and Pierre Jeanneret. Both spent their formative years in the school and had seen Chandigarh being built before their eyes Peter Schaer provided support and guidance and Dr Walter Gyger, Swiss Ambassador to India, and Mr Jagmohan as India’s Minister of Urban Development, patronised the research and wrote the preface.

Insofar as Chandigarh is concerned, a number of books and articles has been written, the most notable of them was by Norma Evensson, "Chandigarh" (1969), followed by Ravi Kalia’s historical analysis "Chandigarh: In Search for Identity" (1987). Both books were well received by students of architecture and city planning, but none really covered in the works undertaken by the two cousins in other parts of India. As the authors state, in particular, Pierre Jeanneret’s works were not so well known earlier so it is appropriate to find a fitting coverage in this book...."

Besides discussing Le Corbusier and Pierre Jeaneret’s work in the country, the book reviews their influence on contemporary architecture, urban design and town planning in post-independence India. The book also covers the works of B.V. Doshi, Jeet Malhotra, S.D. Sharma, Aditya Prakash, Rajindra Kumar, Shivnath Prasad and several others who were inspired and influenced by Le Corbusier.

The book has an unusual arrangement of chapters; "Tale of two colossi", "City planning", "Citadels of democracy", "Poetry of homes", "Hives of work", "Temples of learning", "Corridors of culture", "Footprints" and an extraordinary Epilogue written by Jeet Malhotra who extends the principles he learnt from ustads Corbusier and Jeanneret in planning a new urban India.

Strange it may seem now, the fact remains that Corbusier who came to regard himself as the new prophet of architecture and city planning did not have formal architectural education. His introduction to architecture came via art and sculpture, and he never forsook art. Corbusier used to spend much time in art work, even while visiting Chandigarh in the making. His many paintings and collages, but mainly painting on practically every visit he made when the new city was emerging, are difficult to find. Perhaps the book could provide facsimiles of some of them. He did the abstract tapestry of the High Court building. And designed the abstract design on the main entrance gate of the Assembly building gifted by the government of France. As the authors of the book, Sarbjit and Surinder Bahga state, "The sculptural quality of handmade mud houses in the village fascinated both Corbusier and his cousin". No wonder most of his buildings are more sculptural in form than formal architectural style.

Le Corbusier visutalised his city of tomorrow to be a "radiant city" with basic elements of nature, sunlight and breeze and although at an early stage he thought of his ideal city in terms of very tall structures (skyscrapers) of glass and steel, sited amidst large open spaces, a city enchante surrounded by large open greens, separating pedestrian movement from the vehicular, a city of order, discipline but in complete harmony with nature yet ironically controlled and managed by bureaucracy.

This book on Corbusier and Jeanneret is a significant contribution to the work done in India by the Corbusier cousins and deserves wider circulation. It is excellently produced with lavish illustrations, maps and diagrams - all useful in comprehending the underlying concept of the two living genius of our time, when some of us had the privilege of meeting personally. Hopefully, a less expensive paperback edition would be forthcoming because the price at Rs 1750 is high for most studennts of architecture and planning.