The Tribune - Spectrum
 
ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK



Sunday, November 25, 2001
Books

PUNJABI LITERATURE
Krishna and his role in social change
Review by
Jaspal Singh

WELL-KNOWN Punjabi poet and playwright Swarajbir is a police officer posted in Delhi. His latest play "Krishan" (Chetna Parkashan, Ludhiana) has been keenly debated by scholars and theatre activists. It deals with a phase of Krishna’s life, a divine figure of epic proportions that occurs in several classical texts of India and who is worshipped as God by millions of Indians. The play is a gigantic intellectual effort to understand this legendary character from the standpoint of ancient tribes such as the Bhils, Nagas, Nishads and the Ahirs.

The author, in the introduction to the play, tries to answer some of the main questions about Krishna — who was he, God or an incarnation of God or a mythological hero? At what stage of Indian history did this character emerge as a combination of puranic, mythological and folk hero? In which age did he live if ever he lived at all? In which age did he acquire his present form and meaning? What is the need to have a human incarnation of God? Can God ever acquire a human form? Or can man become God? What is God? What changes this concept has undergone over a period of time? How long did the journey of from the primitive belief in the forces of nature like wind, fire and so on to a belief in God in human form take? When did the idea of a formless, omnipresent, omniscient and beyond the attributes God emerge? Why did the human being need a living God or a God in human form? These are some of the questions that arise in mind while thinking about Krishna.

 


The author admits at the outset that satisfactory answers to such questions are noteasy. He has taken Krishna as a composite image with historical and mythological ramifications and most of his text is based on classical texts of ancient India. There is a constant development in the character of Krishna as it travels across the centuries.

The most accepted biographical sketch of Krishna is like this. He was born in the family of Vasudeva, grew up in Gokul and Brindavan on the banks of the Yamuna. There he defeated Indra, Agni and the serpant god Kalia. Then he shifted to Mathura where he killed his maternal uncle Kansa and made Ugrasen, his maternal grandfather, the king of Mathura. Jarasand and Kalyavan repeatedly invaded Mathura. So Krishna took his people to Kushalthali and founded the city of Dwarka.

In the war of Kurukshetra he fought on the side of the Pandavas, his cousins. It was here he gave the message of the Gita. After the ruin of the Kauravas in the war, he was cursed by Gandhari, their mother, that his own people would also perish like hers. Consequently, Dwarka had a severe famine, followed by a civil war and a tribal invasion. Ultimately the town submerged in the sea. Krishna was killed by Jara, a Bhil, whose forests had been destroyed by Krishna and Arjuna to appease god Agni.

Swarajbir begins his play with a blazing fire in which a forest is burning. Trees, plants, animals and tribals living in the forest are being consumed by it. Krishna and Arjuna claim that the forest has been set on fire to please god Agni. But the author thinks that this is a tale of the victory of the Aryan people over the original inhabitants of Indra and every victor brings devastation to the vanquished.

The first part of Krishna’s life is more sensuous, physical and natural. That is why it is least alienated. The second part of his life begins at Mathura and ends at Dwarka. This is the tale of a power struggle and its legitimation through the discourse of the Gita. But this part of the tale is riddled with dilemmas and irreconcilable contradictions. Hence the Krishna of this play is caught in the maze of these contradictions. Both the Mahabharata and the puranas give clear indication of such a condition.

But if we go back to the history of the concept of god ("A History of God" by Karan Armstrong) the most important stage in the development of this concept comes when the temporal king is invested with divine attributes and is presented as the perfect god. Strangely, Krishna as people’s God is the one who roamed in Gokul and Brindavan, playing with gopis and, above all, with Radha, was fully integrated with nature, and invested with unpolluted innocence and goodness. The politics and the compulsions of the power structure had not yet become part of his consciousness.

This image of Krishna is totally free from alienation. But as he delves deeper in the mechanics of power, he gets alienated and feels absolutely lonely, displaying the usual human passions in action. In fact K.M. Munshi’s novel "Krishna Avtar" gives clear hints of such traits in his character.

As mentioned earlier, the narrative of this play begins with a fire in the Khandare van (forest) which badly hurts the denizens there. In fact, many forests were destroyed by agricultural communities when social transformation from pastoral societies to a settled way of life was taking place. Krishna and Arjuna in this play represent those forces that brought about this change in north India. But when the new order establishes its hegemony, a part of the old is invariably destroyed. That is why the emergence of the new socio-economic-political order always entails turmoil and even violence. The new order then grows and develops on the ruins of the old, of course, retaining whatever is still vital and relevant. The present play has 17 scenes in addition to a prologue and a two-part epilogue. In the first scene the Bhils are talking about the great fire of their forest in which many tribals perished. The Bhils led by Jara resolve to avenge the death of their kin. The next four scenes deal with the socio-political situation obtaining at Dwarka, which in any case is very dismal. There is a severe famine, though the rich and the powerful are frolicking, completely oblivious of the plight of the people in general. There are conspiracies and intrigues everywhere. People feel that the time for the Gandhari’s curse to materialise has arrived. The atmosphere is surcharged with frustration and disappointment.

In the sixth scene the Bhils again appear and they plan their strategy to attack their Aryan enemies. In the next four scenes Krishna is shown to be in council with his wife, his courtiers and commanders. In the 11th scene the Bhils appear in a battle formation and they march to the place where most of the people of Dwarka had congregated for a ritual celebration. In the 12th scene Kali appears and informs Krishna that the time of reckoning has arrived and she exhorts him to reach the field of Prabhash.

In the 13th scene an announcer appears and exhorts the people of Dwarka to reach the field of Prabhash for a celebration. In the next scene the inhabitants are shown in uninhibited celebration in the field of Prabhash drinking and carousing. In the next scene the Dwarkans and their chiefs are shown to be fighting among themselves and killing one another.

Precisely at this hour the Bhils attack the Dwarkans making the best of the fratricidal war. In the last scene Krishana is shown to have been hit by an arrow in his heel by Jara, the Bhil leader. He is in great pain and Jara addresses him thus, "O the one who proclaimed himself to be God, listen! Birth and death, the beginning and the end, are the same for all beings....I made a beginning with a shriek and will depart with a shriek. My life spans between these two shrieks. I may win or lose the battle of life, but today I have won."

The epilogue says, "Myth and history are blended in most of our classical writings... The same Ahirs who once had fought against Krishna along with the Bhils, Nishads, Nagas and other tribes, in course of time accepted Krishna as God.... There is no mention of Radha in the Mahabharata. Long time after the events of the Mahabharata had taken place, Indian literature gave birth to an Ahir or gowala heroine who became famous as the pious beloved of Krishna. The tale goes on and on like this."

The playwright has done thorough research before writing this script. His sources are the Rigved, Chandogya Upnishad, the Mahabharata, Vishnu Purana, Shatpath Brahmana, Srimad Bhagwat, the Bhagwad Gita, Padma Purana, Geeta Govindam and a host of other texts by many well-known Indian and western scholars. It is very rare in Punjabi scholarship that a creative text has taken birth out of this kind of intense research and hard work.

Swarajbir deserves all admiration for taking up such a challenging job while trying to understand the most complex and colourful character of our culture. His sheer effort in itself is a great reward.