The Tribune - Spectrum
 
ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK



Sunday, December 9, 2001
Books

All the big achievers
Review by Jai Narain Sharma

A Touch of Greatness: Encounters with the Eminent
by R.M.Lala. Viking, New Delhi. Pages 238. Rs 295.

NO great man lives in vain. The history of the world is but the biography of great men, said Thomas Carlyle. The modern world revolves at an ever-increasing tempo. Where once a man’s surroundings remained substantially unchanged throughout his lifetime, the speed of life now has so increased that sufficient changes in the pattern of his total environment occur almost every week. The business of just "keeping up" is a real problem.

No newspaper story is thought to be properly slanted unless it deals in personalities. The most complex themes are stated in terms of particular people. Television reinforces the process by appearing to bring every person, famous or unknown, right into the heart of the home.

At the same time so much happens in the 20th century that even famous people quickly get forgotten. A new generation does not know what they looked like. Very often it has little incentive to know what they did. As long ago as 1906 a well-known writer complained that "history is made faster than it can be recorded". Given the greatly superior methods of recording, the remark remains true.

 


To understand the contemporary framework of reference, it is necessary to know about people from all parts of the world and about scientists and engineers as much as about writers and politicians. What is happening has to be placed in its context in space and time.

History is concerned not only with facts but with speculations of this kind and the debates surrounding them. There is still room for new interpretations of Darwin, new discoveries about Dickens, new assessments of Montgomery, remould the World War I, so we can breathe new life into the personalities of the past. Famous people may be quickly forgotten, but people who worked away from the limelight may become far more significant to other people after they are dead than when they were alive.

This book under review, "A Touch of Greatness Encounters with The Eminent" by R.M. Lala, former editor of Himmat and an author of international repute, is for the general reader. At the same time it poses a basic question for historians. For the most part modern history books are not like newspapers or television programmes. They deal less in personalities than in "themes", "tendencies" and "trends". Some of the complex changes of the 20th century seem curiously impersonal; others carry with them a sense of inevitability.

When people are brought in, they are often people of the masses. The famous writer of science fiction, Isaac Asimov, has even suggested that in future we may have what he calls "psycho-history", history that assumes that "the human conglomerate" being dealt with is sufficiently large or valid statistical treatment. Individual decisions become part of a pattern.

It is never easy for the historian to separate individual biography from the social and cultural history in which it is enmeshed or to say confidently what would have happened if a particular individual had not appeared in the world at a particular time. The 26 lives described in this volume have all changed history in different, often ambiguous and contradictory, ways. If they had not existed, we could not have invented them. Once they did exist, their influence moves in many different directions. Historians cannot escape the task of assessing individual motives and achievements. There is no other subject which is concerned in quite the same way with "judgements". Each brief biography in this volume, therefore, will best be appreciated if it is thought of not only as a work of reference but as an invitation to further reading and study.

If we perceive with an open mind, every human being has some good quality which we can emulate with benefit. Over the past five decades, the author had the privilege of meeting or getting to know a number of distinguished men and women. There is a touch of greatness in these personalities and this compels one to search for the secret of their distinction in the context of their lives and times. For example, when Rajaji was urged, then in his late eighties, with his years as Chief Minister of Madras and Governor-General of India, to write his autobiography, he said with modesty, "When the saints of India have not written their lives, who am I to write mine?" When M. S. Subbulakshmi’s husband, Sadasivam, the most faithful of his disciples, urged him to write about his life, he gave the same reply, but added movingly, "Sadasivam, our job is to do our duty and to go." In that one sentence Rajaji summed up what he thought was a man’s purpose in life.

In aprofile of Field Marshal Manekshaw, the author records that when the Japanese were advancing in Burma in early 1942 defending the Sittand Bridge was a 28-year-old captain. Facing a hail of machine-gun bullets, the captain fell to the ground and was left for dead by the retreating forces. His orderly, who had effectively hidden himself during the engagement, came out after the Japanese left. He picked up his unconscious master and carried him on his shoulder the whole day, heading for the town of Prome. He hid the captain in ditches during air raids. When Captain Sam Manekshaw regained consciousness, he told his orderly, "Leave me now and go, for I am finished. You should think of your wife and children and save your life."

"So long as there is life in you, I shall not leave you, Sir," said Mehar Singh. For most of the next night he carried Manekshaw, bringing him to a field hospital. In a tent by candle light at 4 am, an Australian surgeon operated on Manekshaw and removed six bullets from his stomach, lungs and liver. Manekshaw was wrapped up in a blanket and sent off to Rangoon, towards which the Japanese were advancing.

At Rangoon, Manekshaw was told his case was hopeless. There was a ship leaving for Madras. "If you asked to be put on the ship at your own risk, they might take you," the officer advised. Manekshaw told the authorities, "I am going to die in any case. I would rather die in India." It was dangerous journey across the Bay of Bengal but the ship was one of the last to arrive safely to Madras harbour.

Manekshaw was taken to general hospital where surgery saved his life. He was awarded the Military Cross, and spent rest of the war as staff officer at Quetta. It is a wonder that Manekshaw lived. Destiny had a role reserved for him.

The book is full of such narrations. The author records his impressions about luminaries from a wide variety of fields, politics, social activism, industry, religion and the arts — whose life demonstrate "what one can live for — and what one can live byy". Apart from giants like Vinoba Bhave, J.P,.Rajaji, Kripalani, Lal Bhadur Shastri and Morarji Desai who played a prominent role in shaping modern India. R.M. Lal also writes of renowned men and women who have had long and fruitful carriers and still continue to have an impact on our consciousness, among them few are Nani Palkhiwalla, M. S. Subbulakshmi, M. S. Swaminathan and the Dalai Lama.

Among the contemporasry, younger achievers profiled here are Azim Premji who, forced by circumstances to abandon his studies midway, now heads a vast business empire and is rated as the world’s richest Indian, Narayana Murthy who, despite his stellar role in India’s information technology, retains his middle class values. The collection ends with a short autobiographical piece which forms part of the epilogue and is a touching cameo of the author’s father who influenced him immeasurably.

The lesser known facts, the idiosyncrasies and the foibles, the book explores them all, making the people profiled that much more human.

Written with a wealth of detail and a deep sense of empathy and containing 26 illustrations, the book is a must buy for the discerning reader.