The Tribune - Spectrum
 
ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK



Sunday, December 16, 2001
Books

The original Iron Man of India as seen by his daughter
Review by Ashu Pasricha

Inside Story of Sardar Patel: The Diary of Maniben Patel: 1936-50
edited by P. N. Chopra and Prabha Chopra. Vision Books, Delhi. Pages 523. Price Rs 995.

IN recent centuries two events have thrown up a galaxy of talents. The first was when the 13 colonies in America were fighting for their independence. From 1776 to 1783 the USA (as it came to be known later) produced an extraordinary cluster of outstanding men who were the founders of the great republic. In the 25 years between 1922 and 1947, India had a comparable galaxy of talent -- not inferior to that which America produced -- and our leaders combined talent with sterling character. Undoubtedly Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel belonged to the top rank.

Sardar Patel was one of the founders of our Constitution. It was drafted by the Constituent Assembly, which was not elected on the basis of adult franchise. First-rate minds were hand-picked from all parts of India -- for their knowledge, vision and dedication.

Our occasion to ponder over the issue is the book under review "Inside Story of Sardar Patel: The Diary of Maniben Patel: 1936-50"

 


The story of Sardar Patel’s life is easily told. The traditional date of his birth is October 31, 1875. But really speaking, nobody knows the exact day on which he was born. The traditional date is what he gave for his matriculation examination and he never changed it - rather typical of the consistancy which characterised his mental make-up.

He had three great ambitions. First of all, he wanted to consolidate India. In the five thousand years of its history, India was never united: it had always been a group of different states. Vallabhbhai wanted to bring into existence a united, homogeneous India when it became a republic in 1950.

His second ambition was to ensure the survival of a united country through the instrument of a strong civil service. He conceived of the Indian Administrative Service (IAS) in place of the Indian Civil Service (ICS), and it was he who also conceived of the Indian Police Service (IPS). Both these services are very much active today.

His third ambition was to make India economically strong, prosperous and progressive. This ambition remains to be fulfilled.

Among the women who effectively participated in India’s freedom movement, Maniben Patel, Sardar Patel’s daughter, was one of the foremost. She devoted her entire life to the service of the country. She remained unmarried and took care of Gandhi’s health during the prime of her life. Later, for a number of years she took care of her own father. It is widely believed that but for her devoted care, Sardar Patel would not have continued to live as long as he did, nor achieve what he did in India’s service.

Maniben saw to it that people did not tire the Sardar by unduly prolonging their stay. When she felt that discussion on a particular issue wasover, she would caution the visitors that their time was up and that they should leave. If she found that Sardar Patel was at fault in unnecessarily prolonging a discussion, she would hold her watch in front of her father and the Sardar would tell his visitors that he had been shown the watch and warned. She thus prevented him from tiring himself. The nation should be grateful to her for this great service.

Fortunately, Maniben Patel had maintained a diary in which she had recorded what happened during the years she was with her father and took care of his health. She was absolutely honest, keenly observed what happened when people came and met the Sardar, and how the Sardar dealt with the many problems that faced the nation.

Maniben’s diary is of inestimable value to scholars, statesmen and laymen alike. It throws light on the innermost thoughts of Sardar Patel which he could not otherwise express even to his closest friends. Maniben was invariably present with the Sardar at all his meetings excepting, of course, the strictly official ones and would later record whatever transpired in those meetings, particularly Sardar’s views on highly important issues facing the country, the Congress party and the government.

It would appear that Maniben meticulously maintained a diary from 8 June, 1936, till Sardar expired on December 15, 1950. Maniben would note down Sardar’s speeches in Parliament and keep his correspondence handy, besides date-wise notes of visitors and talks conducted with them. Before going to bed, she would make her notes in her diary. She would wake up before the "Pir" Sardar did and get ready to serve him in her multiple roles as Sardar’s daughter, secretary, washerwoman and nurse, all in one. Naturally, no entries were written when the Sardar or Maniben Patel were in prison which was frequent -- during individual satyagraha in 1939 and later on during the Quit India movement in 1942, which kept them both behind bars till 1945.

Maniben has described how she took up the work of secretarial assistance to Sardar Patel at the end of the Bardoli satyagraha in 1928. She writes: "It was suggested that somebody should give him secretarial help…If someone is to be kept, why not I? From 1929 until his death, I preserved his correspondence whenever possible. Once when K.Gopalaswami, political commentator of the Times of India, visited him in his flat on Marine Drive, Bombay, the Sardar called for a letter he had received from C. Rajagopalachari, forgetting that he had torn it up and thrown it in the wastepaper basket. Fortunately, I had collected the pieces. It took me some time to paste them together before passing it on to him. This happened before that Interim Government was formed…

"The Sardar travelled second-class by train before he became a minister. I would spread his bedding at night and retire to a third-class compartment. But from 1934 when there was much correspondence to attend to even on train journeys and people came to see him at the various stations, I kept company with him in his second-class compartment. I used to make copies of important letters he wrote by hand, but he would question this, asking why I was taking such trouble and wasting time. I also kept newspaper clippings of important events with which he was associated.

After 1945, the secretarial functions of the Congress Parliamentary Board were undertaken mainly by Shantilal Shah. The Sardar was undergoing treatment for intestinal trouble at the Nature Cure Clinic, Poona, when he sent for Shantilal Shah from Bombay. Shah, a Congress Socialist, hesitated at first because he did not know what was in store for him. But B.G. Kher, the Premier of Bombay, advised him to take up the work. The Sardar told Shah he wanted him to act as his secretary at the Parliamentary Board Office located at the headquarters of the Bombay Pradesh Congress Committee."

Maniben adds: "I used to sleep by the telephone to take calls that came at odd hours of the night so that father’s sleep was not disturbed. I took down messages and passed them on to him the next morning. One such call came at midnight from Biswanath Das, them Premier of Orissa. He had decided to resign over the choice of a provincial official to act as Governor. The Sardar backed him and the Viceroy yielded."

Even after the Sardar had taken over as Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister, Maniben continued to deal with his Gujarati correspondence, while V. Shankar, Sardar’s Private Secretary, attended to English correspondence.

This immensely significant source of information, originally written in Gujarati in Maniben’s own hand, was never published even in Gujarati, let alone translated into English. This is for the first time that it is being published.

The diary entries of the earlier years are somewhat perfunctory but in the later years, and particularly after the release of Sardar Patel from jail in 1945, they are far move detailed and deal with important and sensitive matters of great import. Sardar expressed his opinions about events and individuals freely and frankly, which were faithfully recorded by his daughter who was like his shadow and accompanied him everywhere.

Her opinion and estimate of many of the leaders and the people Sardar Patel met, which she recorded while her father was still alive, are not only interesting but revealing of the personality of those who met him and of the many problems which they discussed with Sardar and sought his opinion.

Sardar Patel emerges from the diary as a man of action and unbending will, singularly focussed on service to the nation, capable of putting the bigger cause above his own, forthright and blunt, and a man of honour who repeatedly set aside his own ambitions at the request of his mentor. The book also contains a simple, touching estimation of her father by Maniben, as also a comprehensive biographical sketch of Maniben Patel herself.

Maniben Patel’s diary both fills in and fleshes out some of India’s most epochal years, and those of one of its tallest leaders. As such its importance and value for both the scholar and the inquiring citizen can hardly be exaggerated.