SC: Should we wear patriotism on sleeves?

Satya Prakash

Tribune News Service

New Delhi, October 23 

The controversy surrounding the Supreme Court’s order to play the National Anthem in cinema halls took a curious turn on Monday with one of the judges on the three-judge Bench raising questions over making it mandatory. 

“Should we wear our patriotism on our sleeves?” asked Justice DY Chandrachud. “Next thing will be that people should not wear T-shirts and shorts to movies because it will amount to disrespect to the National Anthem... where do we stop this moral policing?” asked Justice Chandrachud, who is part of the Bench headed by Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra. 

(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

Justice AM Khanwilkar is the third judge on the Bench which is hearing petitions seeking recall of the November 30, 2016 order passed by another Bench headed by Justice Misra, which had justified it on the ground that it would “instil a feeling of committed patriotism and nationalism”. 

“There is no mandate that people should stand up when the National Anthem is sung in a cinema hall. This is obviously because a cinema hall is a place for entertainment... people go to cinema halls for undiluted entertainment. Society needs entertainment,” Justice Chandrachud said, referring to the Flag Code. “You don’t have to stand up at a cinema hall to be perceived as patriotic.”

Cultural and social values can’t be enforced through court orders, he said. 

On behalf of the Centre, Attorney General KK Venugopal supported playing of the National Anthem in cinema halls even as the Bench indicated it was open to modifying its 2016 order. 

He, however, said it should be left open to the government to take a call on its own discretion if the National Anthem should be played in theatres and if people needed to stand up for it.

The Bench asked the Centre to consider amending the National Flag Code for regulating the playing of National Anthem in cinema halls across the country and take a call uninfluenced by its earlier order. The Bench indicated that it may modify its order by replacing the word “shall” with “may”, making playing of the National Anthem optional.