Saturday, April 10, 2004
Punjabi channels hold much promise and potential. Far from being regional, they are beamed to several countries. Yet, the fare is lacking in verve and variety. Pop music is the prop on which the channels thrive. There is little else by way of serials, chat shows and current affairs, says Randeep Wadehra
PUNJABI TV? Eyes roll, noses turn up. Enamoured with the hep stuff churned out by Hindi channels, yuppies consider Punjabi television definitely passe – as baassi as last week’s kadi-chawal pulled out from the fridge.
In the good old days, Daarji, Bebeji, Bhappaji, Jhayeeji along with Kaku and Sweety would curl up in front of television, with barrels of cha-sha and heaps of pakoras, to watch DD Jalandhar, the only Punjabi ‘channel’ available to the region. The much-reviled Kendra did come up with some quality programmes that attracted audience across the socio-economic spectrum as well as the international border. Whether it was the rib-splitting Atro-Chatro or a terrorism-related tearjerker, not to mention evocative tele-plays and films, all commanded rapt audience. Several artistes became household names. Pankaj Berry, Vivek Shauq, Jaspal Bhatti, Rama Vij, Preeti Sapru et al were regulars on the desi small screen. Old timers still chortle while recalling Jatinder Kaur’s punchline, "Mera liss liss karda kaddu!" in that tu-tu-main-main teleserial.
The promise held out by the arrival of satellite television got lost in shor-sharaba. Initially, Alpha Punjabi came up with such striking serials as Sarhad, Man Jeete Jag Jeet and popular ones like Jaspal Bhatti’s Prof. Money Plant and Bhagwant Mann’s Jugnu Kehnda Hai. Lori and Patake Tha too are remembered by diehard TV viewers. If Lashkara’s Rano and Do Akal Garh became hit with the public, Chandigarh Campus and Apne Begane too left their mark. Now only repeats and some nondescript in-house comedies are struggling to attract eyeballs. Punjab Mail and Xcuse Me Please often fall flat due to lack of imagination. Frankly, the game shows are borrowed ideas. ETC’s Kaka and Nikki Time targets teenagers, but it remains to be seen whether the kids are captivated.
PTV and Hindi channels are making inroads into rural areas. In the urban areas, the balance is further tilted in their favour. English sitcoms too have a dedicated following. However, youngsters do watch Punjabi pop off and on. Prime time has become dhol time. While Kaku and Sweety gyrate to the beats of Punjabi pop and bhangra rap, Bhappaji and Jhayeeji prefer to have a quiet repast in the bedroom even as Daarji sulks and scowls and Bebeji mutters, "Kee rohla paya hai" Alas, now the family has stopped sitting together for the feast.
While hopping from one
channel to another, one is struck by the uniformity in music quality.
Thematically irrelevant video clips have become constant companions for
songs of love, separation and celebration. Skimpily clad Caucasian
damsels falling all over desi mundas in dense jungles, chic cafes
or posh avenues, is something that has been overdone. It’s like having
pizza topped with sarson da saag. Or, alternatively, you’ve
muscular hunks and chubby lasses going through contortions that are
neither bhangra nor callisthenics. If the songs’ treatment is
pedestrian, their culmination is mediocre. We have a rich heritage of
folk songs and literary compositions that can certainly be produced
aesthetically, sending blood coursing through Punjabi veins. Going for
the so-called fusion music just because it’s in vogue in the West is
too simian to be aped. We Punjabis are known for creativity. Then how
come we have failed to evolve a literary-cultural ethos that would make
us feel proud of our heritage?
"Pride in our heritage remains intact," retorts Rajinder Mohni, a prominent singer, "Look how the Wadali brothers have carved out a following across all age, class and gender groups." He himself is experimenting with qawwali and other Sufi renditions to attract the youth. "In order to enthuse youngsters, one must simplify classical compositions."
In his forthcoming album, Tu Nahin Tay Teri Yaad Sahee, he depicts qawwali in an unconventional manner. While he sings in a fort with Pathans in the background, the accompanying video clip tells the tale-with-tragic-denouement of a lovelorn youth who’s unaware that his beloved is stricken with amnesia. Mohni feels that jazzed-up literary works have a market. He’s planning to produce a video based on Shiv Batalvi’s poetry. If the experiment succeeds, he’ll make video albums featuring other Punjabi poets.
But why does the serial scene evoke yawns? "Lack of professionalism," pronounces producer-director-actor-writer and noted television personality Vijay Tandon, of the national award-winning movie Kachchehri fame. "You can’t enliven the small screen with actors having full-time jobs elsewhere, or students seeking pocket money from this profession." "Unlike Mumbai, we do not have the right environment for nurturing talent," he condemns the system, adding that often payments to artistes and technicians are delayed or withheld. This discourages professionalism. But finance isn’t the only problem, says Tandon. Today, NRIs are financing Punjabi movies in a big way. Most Punjabi channels cannot be described as "regional" since they’re beamed to more than 60 countries. Money can flow into the making of serials too if the channels and the government fashion a conducive environment. "In fact, the government has ignored the Punjabi television industry for too long."
"Things are real bad," laments Bobby Ghai, an industry insider. He sees no hope for revival of serials. "Actors and directors prefer to work for Mumbai banners. Their talent doesn’t get appreciated here." "What talent?" counters Mukesh Gautam, Alpha Punjabi’s head programmer, "The region lacks good directors and actors." Amit Julka, a 24-year-old actor, chimes in, "I’ve acted in serials like Apne Begane and Chandigarh Campus. My role of a student addicted to drugs in the latter got me some recognition, but poor remuneration and uncertain future forced me to take up job with a finance company."
Ghai says that market research is not done to find out viewer preferences, often leading to bad programming. Gautam, however, emphatically denies this, "We do conduct market research. ETC and Alpha – both part of the Zee Group – are number one and two, respectively, in the region. Although the rural Punjab provides us maximum viewership, we have news and current affairs-based programmes, which are watched avidly by people living in places as far away as the UK."
When queried about the financial position of these channels, one encountered abashed silence. But it’s obvious from the quantity and quality of advertisements on various channels that Punjabi television is not exactly in the pink. Only pop shows seem to attract advertisers. "Unlike other channels, we draw top brands for advertisement," Gautam boasts, when asked about corporate patronage for television programmes.
Refuting that only music is being telecast, he says that some comedy serials like Ghuggi Express and Mast Mast continue to be favourites. Yet, he concedes that serious serials haven’t done well and are currently off air, but soon quality programmes based on the works of prominent Punjabi writers will be entertaining the audience. These will attract national viewership, he assures. When queried about the work culture not being conducive to artistic development, he agrees that Punjab, at present, can’t match Mumbai.
It’s a vicious circle. There’s no finance coming because of lack of good scripts. There’re no good scripts because Mumbai holds greater attraction for talented writers. Local talent flounders for want of financial and institutional support. Yet, Punjabi chutzpah may magically resolve the dreadful dilemma.
Let’s say shava to that.
partial to PTV
GIVING Doordarshan a go-by, it is Pakistan Television (PTV) that reigns supreme in places near the India-Pakistan border in Amritsar district. Though most of the Pak telecasts are in Urdu, they are peppered with large doses of Punjabi, thus endearing them to Punjabis in this side of the border.
In the absence of a cable network, except in Attari, old-fashioned aerials can be seen dotting village rooftops. Most border villages receive about four channels, including two Pakistani channels and Doordarshan.
Even as the youth is fond of Indian channels, particularly the Punjabi ones, for their liberal and modern outlook, the village elders cannot resist the attraction of PTV. Capt Hardeep Singh (retd), a resident of Attari, says: "It is safer to watch programmes telecast by Pakistani channels with the family, as they are more sober."
The broadcast of famous Indian Punjabi singer Pammi Bai’s two hit songs on Pakistan television on Basant Panchami, a festival celebrated both in east and west Punjab, added another feather in the PTV cap, remarks Dinesh Kumar, a merchant in Attari.
On Id-ul-Zuha, townships and villages on the entire border belt waited for electricity to be restored to watch the two-day special programmes telecast on PTV and other Pak channels like PTV-2, PTC, and GEO-TV.
Pakistani Punjabi songs are a big hit here despite the fact that Indian Punjabi singers as also our film actors are more popular.
The two Pakistan radio channels FM-100 and FM-2 also have a huge following among villagers in the border areas, who do not receive clear radio signals from AIR. The renditions of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, Nasseebo and Akram Rahi are the most in demand.
Though slapstick comedies and programmes like Des Pardes as also the game show telecast every Saturday are big draws yet what really lures the viewers to PTV are the Pakistani plays and soaps. Plays like Purey Chand Ki Raat, depicting a family feud, are popular among all age groups, while Teen Bata Teen, a comedy serial featuring three boys, finds favour with the young. Lamehy Dariya, a love triangle, Aatish, family drama, and other serials like Tafteesh, Badal, and Ishtarab attract families to the small screen every evening. Earlier plays like Direct Hawaldar and Rambo were also immensely enjoyed by villagers. Sucha Singh, a village headmaster, says most villagers used to imitate Rambo and even dress up like him. "He had quite a following in all border villages." However villagers feel that a play like Laaj on terrorism in Jammu and Kashmir had tried to propagate hatred for India. A programme Punjabi Darbar on Pakistan radio had also tried to stir anti-India sentiment. However, none of this propaganda is taken seriously by villagers.
Conservative village elders find that songs, serials and advertisements shown on Indian channels do not go well with their culture and tradition, and fear that the youth could get corrupted by watching such depraved stuff. In the evenings, in most households, the head of the family decides what must be watched, and invariably all members end up watching PTV programmes. In the morning hours or during holidays, the youth, unsupervised by elders, watch Indian channels.
The Pakistani channels, mostly state controlled, are held on a tight leash by their government. Most of the popular but flashy Pakistani music videos that are a rage on the local cable network in border areas are almost never telecast on Pak channels.