Sincerity crucial in J&K surrender policy : The Tribune India

Join Whatsapp Channel

Sincerity crucial in J&K surrender policy

The sponsored proxy internal conflict in Jammu & Kashmir (J&K) has witnessed a plethora of methods by the state to break the resistance of the terrorist groups through measures other than military.

Sincerity crucial in J&K surrender policy

Reducing alienation: J&K youth need to be assured of employment.



Lt-Gen Syed Ata Hasnain (Retd)

The sponsored proxy internal conflict in Jammu & Kashmir (J&K) has witnessed a plethora of methods by the state to break the resistance of the terrorist groups through measures other than military. It needs to be understood why this is necessary despite a clear advantage that the security forces enjoy in numbers and domination. All over the world, it is well understood that with tight control over resources and effective operations, the strength of terrorists can be brought down to a minimum but the last remnant can rarely be vanquished. A remnant strength mostly remains which takes up a frustratingly large focus without commensurate results, especially if it has local moorings. 

Even marginal success by a lower strength of terrorists helps sustain the movement as is being witnessed in J&K at present. Funeral ceremonies of local terrorists act as motivation for fresh recruitment and the pipeline can be maintained as such for a very long time. At intervals, a new terrorist leader with a charisma a little beyond the ordinary and better organisational skills will emerge and lead the charge, giving an impetus to the movement until he too is neutralised and another upsurge of sentiment is witnessed. 

Little do non-military minds realise that this frustrating cycle can continue interminably. Most such minds favour a kinetic approach towards the neutralisation of the last terrorist. Yet, this is never achievable because there is a finite amount of resources that the state can deploy in the fight against terror; beyond that, it becomes counter-productive. In fact, the returns start diminishing. Lower strength of terrorists tempts hierarchies to reduce force levels and this many times may lead to resurgence of terror activity. 

The state of J&K has witnessed both the above phenomena. The Shopian-Kulgam belt has witnessed a resurgence of such activity due to the space made available to the terrorists after downsizing the Army presence there. We also saw how the killing of Burhan Wani gave energy to local terrorism, leading to resurgence with greater recruitment. 

Now it seems that another charismatic young terrorist leader, Manan Wani, has emerged in South Kashmir. Manan Wani is a former research scholar from Aligarh Muslim University who was pursuing research in applied geology. He has, in all probability, joined the Hizbul Mijahideen. Inquiries to me on social media all harp on whether Mannan Wani is the new Burhan Wani of South Kashmir. 

To beat the flawed approach of attempting to neutralise the last terrorist, we often have weak attempts at trying to break the will of the remnant. One of the ways is through offer of surrender for a reward. It is not easy formulating a surrender policy and it is even more difficult implementing one. We have resorted to such policies many times and each time these have come to a naught, mostly due to the misreading of the environmental reality, insincerity of the bureaucratic and police follow-up and the inability to take it to the last. There is no doubt that on many an occasion, the exploitation of loopholes leads to financial rackets by some marginal elements, such as over ground workers (OGWs). 

In 2003-04, a sincere attempt was made, but the process of verification was weak and took inordinately long to inspire any desire on the part of local terrorists and their families to undergo the same. In addition, there was any number of weapons available for OGWs to purchase at a marginal price and attempt to surrender these to qualify for the label of a terrorist. To beat that, the state government made it mandatory for an individual to be listed as a terrorist in the list maintained by the local intelligence authority. That had its own negative connotations. 

In 2006-07, an attempt was made through a surrender policy to attract back to our side some of the young men who had gone across to PoK in the nineties. Some did manage to return on terms of this policy before it was realised that the Pakistan ISI was attempting to create a few sleeper agents through the legitimate route of the surrender policy. A near-similar attempt was made in 2011-13, but it again came a cropper.

Thus, the reported attempt at a new policy having been formulated in J&K under the current Governor's rule, while being a welcome step, needs circumspection because of experience. On the face, it is revealed that the financial reward is substantially higher at Rs 5-6 lakh, to be placed in a fixed deposit for a lock-in period during which the individual has to showcase his good behaviour. A stipend of Rs 5,000 per month for living expenses will be available during the lock-in period along with some self-employment incentive under the Pradhan Mantri Kaushal Vikas Yojana and Himayat.  

It needs to be remembered that there are an undetermined number of surrendered terrorists in J&K; some figures put them as high as 20,000. No sincere attempt was made to integrate these elements into society and after an initial period during which they were to give 'haazri' (attendance) at local army units or police stations, they simply melted into society. While on one hand it is good that the melt-in effect took place, there remains a nagging doubt about their sense of loyalty and desire to re-enter the bush. In fact, for long it has been felt that with dwindling infiltration the return of surrendered terrorists always remains an option to continue fueling the separatist/terrorist movement. 

What the current hierarchy of security specialists in J&K will have to ensure is that the pitfalls experienced in the last few such surrender policies are closely examined. The financial terms are indeed attractive and this will invite many fraudulent attempts to gain entry to surrender. The successful sustenance of the policy is highly dependent upon the monitoring of the surrendered individuals to ensure they do not subsequently act as OGWs. 

They also need a degree of security for which some separate incentives can be offered to the mohallas and villages they hail from. Self-employment is important, but in J&K this is never easy as people have confidence only in government jobs and these are far and few in a system already bloated with government servants. 

What is needed in Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh is start-up activity with more easily available loans. Large-scale consultancy is required by the J&K Government with India's corporate houses to examine how ancillary support can be provided from these areas for main manufacturing. Horticulture, tourism, including adventure sports, privatised higher education and other traditional methods of employment must be the core areas. 

The success of a surrender policy is also largely contingent upon the degree of alienation existing in the environment. Unless more innovative methods are employed to reduce alienation, a surrender policy will remain in suspense with dubious takers only. Yet, the establishment needs to be complimented for coming out with such a policy so soon after imposition of Governor's rule. 

Top News

Cash-strapped Congress gets fresh IT notice of Rs 1,700 crore, say party insiders

Cash-strapped Congress gets fresh I-T notice of Rs 1,800 crore

Ajay Maken addresses a press conference

Special court convicts 7 people in BSP MLA Raju Pal murder case

Special court convicts 7 people in BSP MLA Raju Pal murder case

The proceedings against Atiq Ahmad, his brother and prime ac...

Arvind Kejriwal's wife releases WhatsApp number for people to send messages for jailed AAP leader

Arvind Kejriwal's wife launches WhatsApp campaign to garner support for AAP leader

In a digital media briefing, Sunita says her husband has cha...

Alka Rai, widow BJP MLA killed by Mukhtar Ansari, says 'justice has been served', visits Ram Mandir

Alka Rai, widow BJP MLA killed by Mukhtar Ansari, says 'justice has been served', visits Ram Mandir

Alka Rai is the wife of MLA Krishanand Rai, who was shot dea...


Cities

View All