Excessive referrals, defunct ambulances under scanner of Haryana Human Rights Commission
Despite the availability of medical specialities, a large number of patients are being referred to private hospitals
The Haryana Human Rights Commission has taken cognisance of a serious matter concerning alleged irregularities and negligence in government hospitals of District Jhajjar and has sought a detailed report from the State health authorities.
It has come to the notice of the Commission that despite the availability of medical specialities, a large number of patients are being referred from District Hospital, Jhajjar and Sub-Divisional Hospital, Bahadurgarh to private hospitals under suspicious circumstances.
Additionally, the condition of ambulance services has been found to be highly concerning, with most vehicles being non-functional and lacking valid fitness certificates.
In the complaint placed before Justice Lalit Batra, the condition of Sub-Divisional Hospital, Beri has also been described as serious, highlighting a lack of essential medical equipment, medicines, and basic facilities. Issues such as the alleged prolonged absence of the Senior Medical Officer, Beri and apathy towards public grievances have also been raised.
Taking these allegations seriously, the Haryana Human Rights Commission observed that if found true, these issues would not only constitute a violation of established governmental norms and healthcare regulations but would also amount to a denial of the right to health, which is an integral part of the right to life.
In this regard, the Chairperson of the Commission, Justice Lalit Batra, has directed the Additional Chief Secretary, Health & Family Welfare, Medical Education & Research and AYUSH, Haryana; the Director General, Health Services, Haryana, Panchkula; and the Civil Surgeon, Jhajjar to submit a detailed, factual, and time-bound report addressing all allegations raised in the complaint. The report must also clearly specify the remedial measures taken or proposed to address the deficiencies.
The report should specifically include the following points:
- Details and justification of the large number of patient referrals made from District Hospital, Jhajjar and Sub-Divisional Hospital, Bahadurgarh, along with the data in the context of the number of medical specialities available in these hospitals.
- Operational status, maintenance records, and fitness certification of all ambulances in District Jhajjar;
- Availability and functionality of essential infrastructure, equipment, medicines, and basic facilities in government hospitals of District Jhajjar;
- Details regarding the prolonged absence, if any, of the Senior Medical Officer, Beri.
As per the directions of the Haryana Human Rights Commission, the concerned authorities are required to submit their detailed report on the above-mentioned points at least one week prior to the next date of hearing, i.e., August 20.



