Quality concerns cloud construction of proposed fire station at Naduan
Unlock Exclusive Insights with The Tribune Premium
Take your experience further with Premium access. Thought-provoking Opinions, Expert Analysis, In-depth Insights and other Member Only BenefitsConstruction of the retention wall for the proposed fire station in Naduan — Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu’s Assembly constituency — has come under scrutiny following allegations of poor workmanship. Residents claim that the agency executing the project used oversized, heavily soiled stones in the wall, raising serious questions about structural integrity.
The fire station was announced by the CM to ensure quick emergency response in the region. For this purpose, land near Harmandir village, close to the town, was identified and land development began for the upcoming facility. However, locals say the quality of the retention wall has been “compromised from the start,” dampening hopes pinned on the project. The construction is reportedly being carried out by the BSNL construction wing.
Sunil Kumar, a resident of the area, alleged that contractors were filling the wall with unusually large stones “simply to reduce the use of crushed grit and cement.” He said such practices weaken the wall’s structural strength. “The stones are also heavily soiled and muddy,” he added.
Ramesh, another resident who was present at the site, said muddy stones should at least be washed before use. “If the stones remain coated with mud, they do not bind properly with the cement-grit mixture and stay loose,” he said.
Viney Kumar, Commandant of the Home Guards, said he would look into the concerns raised by residents. He added that land development is still in progress and the issues flagged would be examined.
Madan Lal, SDO (Civil) of BSNL, acknowledged that there is a provision for filling up to 40 per cent of the retention wall with stones. He said he visits the site regularly but had been unable to do so for three days due to an audit inspection. “I will ensure that the construction quality is not compromised,” he assured.