The Pioneer and the Lahore High Court : The Tribune India

Join Whatsapp Channel

Lahore, Sunday, October 9, 1921

The Pioneer and the Lahore High Court



In a recent issue, we had something to say about the attack by the Pioneer on the Lahore High Court in connection with the proposal to transfer the judicial administration of the N.W. Frontier Province to that Court. Among the allegations which the journal made against our High Court were:--(1) “It is in its infancy as a High Court” and (2) “from the remarks of the speakers in Wednesday’s debate it has yet to win its spurs as fit to stand beside the other High Courts of the country by reason of its judicial reputation.” As regards the second of these allegations, we have been at pains to go through some of the more important speeches delivered on the official side during the debate, as published in the official report, but we have not come across anything justifying the Pioneer’s remark that the Lahore High Court is yet to win its spurs. This, for instance, is what we find in Dr. Sapru’s speech, and Dr. Sapru was the foremost spokesman of the Government on the occasion:-- “Give back this Province to the High Court which, you say, is not quite so good as the Madras High Court or the Calcutta High Court.” Dr. Sapru does not identify himself or the Government with the opinion. The only High Courts he mentions are those of Madras and Calcutta, while the Pioneer’s remark is far more sweeping and includes the High Courts at Bombay, Allahabad and Patna, with two of which at least the Lahore High Court cannot be said even by its worst detractors to compare unfavourably. There is nothing in the remark to show that Dr. Sapru was thinking of judicial reputation at all, and not of some of the other things to which the Pioneer refers. Both Dr. Sapru and Pioneer forget that the sole issue in this case is not whether the Punjab High Court is an ideal High Court, but whether it is not incomparably better than a Judicial Commissioner’s Court.


Top News

US sanctions Chinese suppliers for providing critical components of Pakistan’s ballistic missile programme

US sanctions Chinese suppliers for providing critical components of Pakistan’s ballistic missile programme

As a result of the action, all property and interests in pro...

Iraq's popular mobilization forces post hit in air strike, sources say

Iraq's popular mobilization forces post hit in air strike, sources say

US official said there had been no US military activity in I...

Indian student's death in US possibly linked to 'Blue Whale Challenge': Report

Indian student's death in US possibly linked to 'Blue Whale Challenge': Report

The 20-year-old, who will remain unnamed here in deference t...

Tesla's Elon Musk postpones India trip, sources say

Elon Musk postpones India visit, cites ‘very heavy’ Tesla obligations

The Tesla CEO wrote on X that he is looking forward to comin...


Cities

View All