Saturday, February 22, 2003
T H I S  A B O V E  A L L

When minds donít meet
Khushwant Singh

THE varieties of man-woman relationship is mind-boggling. Many years ago, a young English girl, a qualified architect, came to India. She found herself in Calcutta with very little money. She was directed to the gurdwara in Hooghly where she could stay and eat a few days free of charge. The sewadar of the gurdwara let her in and gave her daal and chappatis. He could not speak a word of English, she not a word of Punjabi, Hindi or Bengali. He showed her round Calcutta. They went on foot, tram and cycle-rickshaws. Without much exchange of words, they became lovers and decided to get married. He brought her to his village in Punjab where they lived together. She adapted herself to village life, eating Indian food, and going to the fields to defecate. There was a lot of meeting of the bodies but no meeting of the minds. Both realised their relationship could not last. Their shortlived romance ended at Delhiís Palam airport. They spent early part of the night lying on the lawn outside. When her flight was called, they simply wished each other Sat Sri Akal and went their separate ways. The English girl turned the episode into a touching love story, which was later published in England and India.

Love in times of war
February 15, 2003
Intriguing facts about elephants
February 8, 2003
Surviving yet another cold war
February 1, 2003
The NRI jamboree
January 25, 2003
Farid Shakarganj of Pak Pattan
January 18, 2003
Who is responsible for the plight of our daughters?
January 11, 2003
The not-so-great Churchill
January 4, 2003
Pritam Singh: Bhapaji of the Punjabi literary world
December 14, 2002
Rarest of the rare
December 7, 2002
Begums and their sahibs
November 30, 2002

We have a parallel story, more bizarre than that of the sewadar and the girl architect. An English upper middle-class woman divorcee with five grown-up children comes to India to set up a travel agency. On arrival at the I.G.I. Airport in Delhi, she is received by a Haryanvi taxi driver holding a placard with her name Jill Lowe in his hands. He has been deputed by his employer to receive the lady and take her wherever she wants to go. He is in his early forties, a widower with four children living in his village. He can only speak a few sentences of English. He takes the lady across India. At Orchha (Madhya Pradesh), they find only one room in the rest house which they have to share.

They spend the night together and decide they were made for each other. She spends some days with his family in the village, eating with them on the floor, sleeping on a charpoy and going out to the fields to relieve herself. They go through several marriage ceremonies, a final one in court. They are not living in a flat in Delhi, running their own taxi service. The lady has turned her experience into an autobiographical novel: Yadav: A Roadside Love Story (Penguin).

The Yadavs came to call on me. I was told he loved his drink; I had a bottle of Scotch laid out for him. He did not touch it. When his wife, I and one of my nieces who had dropped in poured ourselves drinks, he took his mug of tea to another room because the smell of alcohol gave him a headache. He is no Romeo. He is dark-skinned but well preserved. She is a genteel, soft-spoken lady and looks younger than her years. She looks after him like a mother. She took him with her to meet her family in England, hoping he would settle down with them. He could not stand the English climate or the food and flew back to Haryana. There is a still not much meeting of the minds. I wonder how long the mutual infatuation will last.

The two stories got me thinking on the strange combinations and permutations in men-women relationships. Do people fall in love before they have sex? Or does sex come first and is hopefully followed by love? Do differences in ages of the two determine their future? Usually men marry women younger than them but there are many cases where they marry women old enough to be their mothers. Can there be a close relationship between men and women in the same age group without a physical relationship? I do not think so. As an English poet wrote: "One who falls in love without taking it to the final conclusion, is like one who goes on a sea voyage only to become sea-sick."

Holy writing

I read the holy scriptures of all religions: Hinduism, Hebrew, Christianity, Islam Sikhism ó because they are beautifully worded. Since I am not familiar with languages in which they were originally written (except the Sikhsí Guru Granth Sahib), I read them in translation. Everyone of them has been translated many times by scholars in an effort to make them word-perfect. Without subscribing to any particular faith, I enjoy reading their holy books. I find nothing contradictory in my behaviour.

I stand rebuked. My long time friend Jaya Thadani, daughter of the late Justice Dalip Singh is a devout Catholic. I have not met her for almost 40 years because she lives in London with her Sindhi Hindu husband for most of the time and they spend some months of the year in the States with their son, daughter-in-law and grandchildren. She refuses to return to Delhi: her India was Lahore and she finds the social and political climate in India unwholesome. We write to each other regularly. I look forward to hearing from her. In the last few letters, she reproached me for having the wrong approach to scriptural texts. With her last letter, she sent me Thomas A Kempisís Counsels On the Spiritual Life (Penguin). Chapter five of the booklet is "On Reading The Holy Scriptures". Kempis writes. "In the holy scriptures truth is to be looked for rather than fair phrases... We should seek food for our souls rather than subtleties of speech, and have no concern to appear learned." According to Kempis, I read scriptural writing for wrong reasons: for fair phrases, subtleties of speech and to appear learned. I am not the slightest bit contrite. It is the language of scriptures not their logic which appeals to me; I also succumb to the temptation of showing off my little knowledge by quoting from them. But at no time have fair phrases or subtleties translated themselves into a set of beliefs or subscription to a particular religion. I enjoy good writing. I like reading poetry, poetic prose are witty phrases. I am not a humbug.


Colonel Powell walked into the White House drawingroom unannounced to find himself in a room filled with the CNN and BBC television cameras.

He was shocked to see President Bush and Defence Secretary Ronald Rumsfeld, face to face, with drawn swords in their hands, lunging at each other.

"Hey!" Powell shouted: "What the hellís going on here? you can hurt yourself with those things!"

"Donít worry!" said Bush, "We are only engaging in sabre-rattling to scare the hell out of Saddam!"

(Contributed by Priya Nath Mehta, Gurgaon)