'Sanatan Dharma' remark: No fresh FIR against TN Deputy CM Udhayanidhi Stalin, orders SC

No fresh FIRs should be filed against Tamil Nadu Deputy Chief Minister M Udhayanidhi Stalin for his “eradicate Sanatan Dharma” remarks without its permission, the Supreme Court ordered on Thursday.

Acting on a petition filed by the Tamil Nadu Deputy Chief Minister, a Bench led by Chief Justice of India Sanjiv Khanna also extended its interim order granting him protection against coercive actions in cases registered against him in connection with his alleged remarks.

The order came after senior advocates AM Singhvi and P Wilson submitted on behalf of the son of Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin that a fresh FIR had been registered against him in Bihar.

The Bench allowed Udhayanidhi to amend his petition to add the new complainants in his pending case and posted the matter for hearing on April 21.

Likening Sanatan Dharma to coronavirus, malaria and dengue, Udhayanidhi had in September 2023 allegedly called for its eradication.

Referring to its orders for clubbing of FIRs in cases against TV journalist Arnab Goswami, AltNews co-founder Mohammed Zubair and former BJP spokesperson Nupur Sharma, Singhvi urged the top court to transfer the cases against Udhayanidhi to another state, preferably Karnataka, for trial.

On behalf of the Maharashtra Government, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta wondered what would have happened if a chief minister of some other state had called for eradication of a particular religion, say Islam. “Merely because a community sought to be eradicated does not react in a violent way, this (eradicate Sanatan Dharma) can’t be said,” Mehta argued.

However, the Bench refused to go into the merits of the case. “We will not like to comment upon any words because they have an impact on the trial,” the Bench said.

As Mehta said the matter should be taken up with another petition on hate speech pending before another Bench, the CJI said the other matter dealt with the larger issue of hate speech and not individual hate speeches.