AFT dismisses Verma’s claim to Navy’s top post : The Tribune India

Join Whatsapp Channel

AFT dismisses Verma’s claim to Navy’s top post

CHANDIGARH:Dismissing the claim of Vice Admiral Bimal Verma for appointment to the post of Chief of the Navy, the Armed Forces Tribunal has upheld the elevation of the next senior most naval officer.

AFT dismisses Verma’s claim to Navy’s top post

Vice Admiral Bimal Verma



Vijay Mohan

Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, September 16

Dismissing the claim of Vice Admiral Bimal Verma for appointment to the post of Chief of the Navy, the Armed Forces Tribunal has upheld the elevation of the next senior most naval officer.

In its order today, the Tribunal’s Bench comprising Justice Virender Singh and Lt Gen Philip Campose ruled that seniority in the panel of Vice Chief of Naval Staff and Commanders-in-Chief is the primary consideration, but cannot be the sole criterion for selection of important appointments like the Chief of Naval Staff (CNS). The post of CNS is not a promotion post, but an appointment by the President. 

Observing that negative records, which come to the notice of the government can be taken note of by them, while considering those in the zone of consideration for the post, the Tribunal held that the respondents were justified in their action in superseding the applicant when they, as per their discretion, which is clearly recorded on the file, found that the applicant, though the senior most, was not fit for selection as CNS and thereby appointed the next senior most officer found fit for selection.

Vice Admiral Verma, then Flag Officer Commanding-in-Chief (C-in-C, Andaman and Nicobar Command, had challenged the appointment of Admiral Karambir Singh, then C-in-C, Eastern Naval Command, as the Navy Chief, alleging mala fide and bias. The latter took over as the Navy Chief on May 30.

The Tribunal observed the applicant had been awarded severe displeasure on two occasions, the first in 2005 for acts of omission and commission with regard to his role as the Principal Director, Naval Operations, during the Navy War Room leaks, which was serious enough to have resulted in the dismissal from service of three of his subordinates, and the other in 2007 for an act of negligence in having authorised a flight of an unserviceable Chetak helicopter while commanding INS Mysore.

Top News

Curtains on campaigning for 7th and final phase of Lok Sabha election 2024

Curtains on high-decibel campaigning for 7th and final phase of Lok Sabha election 2024

States going to polls in last phase include Punjab, Himachal...

Sexual abuse: Hassan MP Prajwal Revanna returns to country, arrested by SIT at airport

Sexual abuse: Hassan MP Prajwal Revanna returns to country, arrested by SIT at airport

A large number of policemen were deployed there to ensure th...

PM Modi begins ‘dhyan’ at Kanyakumari Vivekananda Rock Memorial

PM Modi begins ‘dhyan’ at Kanyakumari Vivekananda Rock Memorial

Ahead of his departure on June 1, Modi is likely to visit Th...

Mines explode after forest fire along LoC in J-K’s Poonch; blaze engulfs forests of Samba and Jammu

Mines explode after forest fire along LoC in J-K’s Poonch; blaze engulfs forests of Samba and Jammu

Locals allege some miscreants are triggering fire due to som...

Slew of fires keep forest staff on toes in Himachal Pradesh’s Solan and Kasauli

Slew of fires keep forest staff on toes in Himachal Pradesh’s Solan and Kasauli

Forest fire halts Kalka-Shimla train 15 km before its destin...


Cities

View All