US judge dismisses charges against Indian-origin doctor accused of genital mutilation

Dr Jumana Nagarwala had sought a dismissal of a charge of conspiracy to travel with intent to engage in illicit sexual conduct involving two 7-year-old Minnesota girls

US judge dismisses charges against Indian-origin doctor accused of genital mutilation

Photo for representation purposes.

Washington, September 29

A US federal judge has dismissed new charges against an Indian-origin doctor accused of performing female genital mutilation, in what is believed to be the first-of-its-kind case in the country, according to media reports.

Dr Jumana Nagarwala had sought a dismissal of a charge of conspiracy to travel with intent to engage in illicit sexual conduct involving two 7-year-old Minnesota girls who were brought to Metro Detroit for what prosecutors call an illegally performed procedure, The Detroit News reported.

The case is believed to be the US’ first involving female genital mutilation and emerged in April 2017 when Nagarwala was arrested and accused of heading a conspiracy that lasted 12 years and involved seven other people, it said.

Judge Bernard Friedman dismissed the fourth superseding indictment prosecutors had filed in the case, ruling that it amounted to a vindictive prosecution.

Nagarwala was accused of performing genital mutilation on nine girls at a suburban Detroit clinic. She denies any crime and says she performed a religious custom. The girls were from Illinois, Michigan and Minnesota.

She and three others were charged in April 2017 under a Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) statute passed by Congress.

Judge Friedman dismissed those charges in 2018 after ruling the statute was unconstitutional. Friedman ruled that Congress did not have the power to enact a federal law that banned female genital mutilation in the United States.

Prosecutors in March 2021 added charges of making false statements to federal officers and tampering with witnesses.

Friedman called the latest alterations to the lingering case “clearly unreasonable and indicative of vindictiveness”, and ordered a dismissal in a ruling issued on Tuesday.

“It is unreasonable for the prosecutor to bring any of these charges in light of the court's ruling that the FGM (female genital mutilation) statute is unconstitutional,” MLive Media Group quoted Friedman as saying.

“All of the charges presented in the fourth superseding indictment require a showing that defendants committed, or conspired to commit, a federal offence...It is alleged that defendants falsely told law enforcement that FGM was not being performed in their community and that they conspired to, and did, tell community members to give law enforcement the same misinformation.

"But telling such lies, conspiring to do so, and coercing others to do so was not a crime during the time frame at issue (May 2016-April 2017) because the statute making FGM a federal offence was unconstitutional," Friedman said.

The government argued that female genital mutilation was a federal offence until the court declared the law unconstitutional in November 2018.

“The court rejects this argument,” Friedman wrote in his ruling. “The court's ruling that Congress lacked the authority to pass (the ban) means that the statute was void ab initio (from the beginning).”

The procedure, female genital mutilation (FGM), is practised by some members of the Dawoodi Bohra, a Muslim sect from India that has a small community in Metro Detroit.

Authorities allege Minnesota mothers Haseena Halfal and Zainab Hariyanawala brought their daughters to Detroit in February 2017 for the procedure.

Authorities said the trip constituted a federal crime, which carries a penalty of up to 30 years in prison and a USD 250,000 fine. PTI

Tribune Shorts

Top Stories

Amit Shah reiterates ‘roadmap’ for J-K polls and statehood restoration, reaches out to youth

Amit Shah reiterates ‘roadmap’ for J-K polls and statehood restoration, reaches out to youth

Government will not allow anyone to create hurdles in the pa...

Singapore removes India, 5 other South Asian nations from travel restriction list

Singapore removes India, 5 other South Asian nations from travel restriction list

Travellers will, however, be subjected to the tightest of bo...

CISCE to conduct board exams in offline mode, announces revised date sheet

CISCE to conduct board exams in offline mode, announces revised date sheet

Exams for Class 10 from November 29 and December 16; from No...

Want to join Congress? Must pledge to not criticise party publicly and to stay off drugs, liquor

Want to join Congress? Must pledge to not criticise party publicly and to stay off drugs, liquor

CWC recently approved organisational election schedule of th...

Travel blogger from Himachal, living in California, was among 2 killed in Mexico's Tulum

Travel blogger from Himachal, living in California, was among 2 killed in Mexico's Tulum

Anjali Ryot and the German woman were killed, while the thre...

Cities

View All