Contentious EIA draft

Govt must consider the feedback on proposed Bill

Contentious EIA draft

Photo for representation only

Nearly 17 lakh people have responded, mostly angrily, to the draft Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) 2020 notification that was issued by the Environment Ministry in March this year. They have given thousands of suggestions and critiques on the proposals outlined in the draft regarding the procedure of issuing environmental clearances to various projects. The massive public feedback — the deadline for which was extended by the Delhi High Court to August 11 — is reflective of the huge concern for ecology as also activism in the field prompted by the all-round degradation of the atmosphere, be it soil, air or water. Given that pollution continues to take a toll on lives and livelihoods, everybody is a stakeholder in the business of cleaning up the act.

As new ventures continue to mushroom with impunity in the name of development, the affected millions are rightly aghast at the draft that has little to afford by way of reining in the rogue industries and developers. Rather, certain provisions in the draft point to a dilution of the stringent penal provisions of the earlier Environmental Protection Act (2006), shifting the balance in favour of unrestrained economic growth and giving short shrift to ecological concerns. The Congress has joined the public outpouring of outrage, particularly against the provision which seeks to give the clean chit to industries set up without valid environmental clearances through ex post facto approvals, granted with payment of a penalty amount. This is likely to hit a legal hurdle as it goes contrary to a Supreme Court ruling that has struck down such approvals as ultra vires of the parent Act and illegal.

The government would do well to look into the suggestions aimed at taming the devastation to environment by strengthening the compliance rules. Short-term economic gains with environmental hazards are myopic. While Environment Minister Prakash Javadekar has given an assurance to the effect, it remains to be seen how much he bends.

Top Stories

Mizoram Police book Assam chief minister, 4 senior cops in border row

Mizoram Police book Assam chief minister, 4 senior cops in border row

They have been booked under various charges, including attem...

Tokyo Olympics: PV Sindhu loses to Tai Tzu in semifinals, to fight for bronze now

Tokyo Olympics: PV Sindhu loses to Tai Tzu in semifinals, to fight for bronze now

Indian shuttler to compete against China’s He Bing Jiao in t...

Babul Supriyo to leave politics; to quit as MP

Babul Supriyo to leave politics; to quit as MP

Former Union minister, who lost ministerial berth recently, ...

Top Pak militant killed in Kashmir is Jaish chief's relative and a Pulwama attack conspirator

Top Pak militant killed in Kashmir is Jaish chief's relative and a Pulwama attack conspirator

Police say Mohd Ismal Alvi, alias Lamboo, was family member ...

Chandigarh's miracle mom Mann Kaur dies at 105

Chandigarh's miracle mom Mann Kaur dies at 105

The veteran athlete had been suffering from cancer

Cities

View All