Shubhadeep Choudhury
New Delhi, May 10
Archaeological Survey of India’s (ASI) decision to keep mum on the controversy triggered by a BJP functionary who has petitioned in the Allahabad High Court seeking directives to the ASI to open 20 rooms inside the Taj Mahal to check for the possible presence of Hindu idols is raising eyebrows.
The petition, filed by Rajneesh Singh, BJP media in-charge of Uttar Pradesh’s Ayodhya district, is yet to come up for hearing.
“Around 20 rooms in the Taj Mahal are locked and no one is allowed to enter. It is believed that in these rooms, there are idols of Hindu gods and scriptures,” the petition said.
The petitioner has also sought directives to the state government to constitute a committee to examine the 20 rooms inside the world-famous Mughal era monument.
“The matter is in the court and we will not like to say anything at the moment,” an ASI spokesperson said.
“The claim about the Taj is absurd. The petition should not have been allowed,” R Nandakumar, noted art historian and former fellow of Nehru Memorial Museum and Library, said. “The ASI’s stand to keep quiet on the issue amuses me,” Nandakumar added.
Similar sentiment was also expressed by historian S Irfan Habib. “The ASI is part of the government. Everyone knows what the present government at the Centre thinks on issues such as the one that has come up before the Allahabad High Court,” Habib remarked.
Claims that the Taj Mahal is a Hindu temple have surfaced periodically, either from a lone Hindu radical or members of Hindu right-wing groups, ever since PN Oak, a writer with the pretensions to being a history enthusiast, published his 1989 book ‘Taj Mahal, the True Story: The Tale of a Temple Vandalised’, in which he claimed it was built before the Islamic rule was established in India.
Oak, who died in 2007, took his claim as far as the Supreme Court in 2000, where it was thrown out as no more than a “bee in his bonnet”.
That a lower court took up the case despite the Supreme Court making a strong observation with regard to the claim that the Taj was a Hindu temple has also surprised scholars.
A short history of the Taj Mahal chronicled in ASI’s Agra Circle website describes the monument as “built by the Mughal emperor Shah Jahan, grandson of Akbar the Great, in memory of his queen Arjumand Bano Begum, entitled ‘Mumtaz Mahal’”.
Unlock Exclusive Insights with The Tribune Premium
Take your experience further with Premium access.
Thought-provoking Opinions, Expert Analysis, In-depth Insights and other Member Only Benefits
Already a Member? Sign In Now