Right to protest can’t be anytime, everywhere: Supreme Court

Dismisses plea seeking review of its Oct 7 verdict on anti-CAA protesters

Right to protest can’t be anytime, everywhere: Supreme Court

The Supreme Court (SC) has dismissed a petition seeking review of its Shaheen Bagh verdict that said roads and public spaces couldn’t be blocked indefinitely and demonstrations had to be in designated places.

Tribune News Service

New Delhi, February 13

The Supreme Court (SC) has dismissed a petition seeking review of its Shaheen Bagh verdict that said roads and public spaces couldn’t be blocked indefinitely and demonstrations had to be in designated places.

Dismisses review plea in shaheen bagh case

  • SC dismisses plea seeking review of its Oct 7 verdict on anti-CAA protesters
  • It had said public space can’t be blocked indefinitely and protest has to be held in designated places
  • Petitioners allege the court stance appears ‘giving way to unrestricted sanction to police action’

“The right to protest cannot be anytime and everywhere. There may be some spontaneous protests but in case of prolonged dissent or protest, there cannot be continued occupation of public places affecting the rights of others,” a three-judge Bench headed by Justice SK Kaul said.

“We have considered the earlier judicial pronouncements and recorded our opinion that the Constitutional scheme comes with a right to protest and express dissent but with an obligation to have certain duties,” said the Bench, which also included Justice Aniruddha Bose and Justice Krishna Murari.

Maintaining that “democracy and dissent go hand in hand”, the SC had on October 7 last year ruled that roads and public space couldn’t be blocked indefinitely and demonstrations expressing dissent had to be in designated places.

However, review petitioner Kaniz Fatima and 11 other Shaheen Bagh protesters had requested the top court to reconsider its ruling, saying the judgment “appeared to be giving way to an unrestricted sanction to the police to take action by misusing these observations.”

The protesters, who had blocked the Kalindi Kunj-Shaheen Bagh stretch in Delhi since December 15, 2019, were removed on March 24 after Covid lockdown was enforced.

Tribune Shorts

Top Stories

Prime Minister Narendra Modi meets US Vice President Kamala Harris

Prime Minister Narendra Modi meets US Vice President Kamala Harris

Harris described India as a "very important partner" to the ...

2 killed in police firing during eviction drive in Assam’s Darrang, govt orders judicial probe

2 killed in police firing during eviction drive in Assam’s Darrang, govt orders judicial probe

Video shows official photographer hitting dead man; Rahul Ga...

Covid vaccine at home for differently abled, people with restricted mobility: Centre

Covid vaccine at home for differently abled, people with restricted mobility: Centre

66 per cent India adults covered with 1 Covid shot, 23 per c...

Ruckus at Chandigarh airport as 30 passengers not allowed to board Sharjah flight

Ruckus at Chandigarh airport as 30 passengers not allowed to board Sharjah flight

Passengers not fulfilling Covid guidelines issued by UAE

Supreme Court to set up expert panel to probe Pegasus row; order expected next week

Supreme Court to set up expert panel to probe Pegasus row; order expected next week

CJI NV Ramana says he wanted to pass an order this week but ...

Cities

View All