Letters to the editor

Refer to ‘Infiltrators, inheritance and desperation’ (Nous Indica); as the election fervour grips the nation, the BJP has returned to divisive tactics and the Opposition is giving a faltering response, evoking a sense of déjà vu. PM Narendra Modi’s recent speech in Banswara, replete with references to infiltrators, mangalsutras and family size, raises concerns. Is this desperation or a calculated move? The BJP’s resort to communal signalling underscores its unease. However, economic woes, not religious rhetoric, dominate the public discourse. While the BJP battles complacency, the Congress’ confusion impedes its resurgence. Rahul Gandhi’s calls for revolution will ring hollow without concrete action. In this electoral maze, the electorate seeks substance over spectacle and solutions over slogans.

Gurdev Singh, by mail

Electorate’s wish for progress

With reference to ‘Infiltrators, inheritance and desperation’ (Nous Indica); in the throes of an electoral battle, the air is thick with desperation and divisive rhetoric. PM Narendra Modi and the BJP’s resort to polarising narratives, notably at the Banswara rally, is a disheartening echo of past tactics. This strategic retreat to the ‘safety zone’ of communal discourse signals more than just campaign fervour; it hints at an underlying fear of losing its grip. The Opposition’s entanglement in its own contradictions only adds to the political drama. Yet, it is the electorate’s response that will deliver the final act. If the BJP’s communal call fails to resonate, it may well be a reflection of the public’s weariness with polarisation and a yearning for unity and progress.

Sahibpreet Singh, Mohali

The poll promise that was not

Refer to ‘Anxiety in the saffron camp’; among the election-related issues, the writer mentioned the BJP’s reported ‘promise’ of transferring Rs 15 lakh into every Indian’s bank account. But no such promise was made by anyone. What PM Modi had reportedly said was that there was enough black money stashed in foreign banks to be distributed at the rate of over Rs 15 lakh to individuals in India. Can it be called a poll promise? The black money, if unearthed, should go to the state exchequer, not into the accounts of individuals. Only a naïve person would think otherwise. Though the Opposition keeps raking up the issue, at least an enlightened and well-informed writer must not do so.

WG CDR CL Sehgal (retd), Jalandhar

SC right to junk EVM-VVPAT pleas

With reference to the editorial ‘EVMs get SC backing’; the Supreme Court has rightly junked the pleas seeking 100 per cent verification of Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) votes with their Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trail (VVPAT) slips. The apex court also observed that the weakness of the ballot paper system is well known and manual counting is prone to human errors. It could also lead to deliberate mischief. The demand for cross-verification of votes by members of Opposition parties was driven by frustration triggered by a number of electoral losses across the country. Notably, Opposition leaders never question the functioning of EVMs when they register a win. The court did the right thing.

MD Sharma, Shimla

Reposing faith in voting system

Apropos of ‘EVMs get SC backing’; all right-thinking people must welcome the apex court’s rejection of the petitions seeking 100 per cent verification of EVM votes with their VVPAT slips. The SC has ruled out a return to the paper ballot voting system, which used to witness large-scale attempts by goons with political patronage to capture polling booths. Candidates now have the option to request an inspection of at least 5 per cent of EVMs in each Assembly segment in every parliamentary constituency within seven days of the declaration of the result. It would deter them from questioning the reliability of EVMs without any grounds. Besides, there remains a scope for continual improvement in the efficacy of the machines through the latest technological methodologies and interventions.

Krishan Kant Sood, Nangal

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit.

These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of ‘Anxiety in the saffron camp’; it was a thought-provoking article. The writer has aptly pointed out that there was palpable anxiety in Prime Minister Modi’s voice when he accused the Congress of preparing to take away gold and silver jewellery collected over the years by BJP supporters and distributing it among the minorities, especially Muslims. He could have easily avoided these observations, which have, directly or indirectly, created a gulf between communities. However, voters are well aware of our leaders and their political agendas.

SUBHASH C TANEJA, GURUGRAM

Whose mistake?

Apropos of the news report ‘EC notice to BJP on PM’s Rajasthan rally; Rahul puts Cong in trouble too’; in a complete departure from the past, the ECI has refrained from naming PM Modi and Congress star campaigner Rahul Gandhi in separate notices to rival parties. The notices have been sent to the respective party presidents. It is like reprimanding a father when the son has committed a folly. Is the ECI scared of naming the Prime Minister, who has repeatedly violated the model code of conduct? What example has he set for others? It is up to the people now to decide who is wrong or right. What signals is the Election Commission sending out to the masses? Can we expect a free and fair election?

capt Amar Jeet (retd), Kharar

Tesla in India

Referring to the article, ‘Tesla’s troubles and Musk’s delayed tryst with India’; investment and production of Tesla electric vehicles (EVs) will give a much-needed push to the EV ecosystem in the country. Perhaps it was one of the reasons the Indian government announced the e-vehicle policy before the model code of conduct came into effect. High-profile billionaire Elon Musk has already acknowledged that India is the world’s fastest-growing car market as it is the most populous country. An affordable car is critical to Tesla’s success in India. Tesla is looking for fresh markets after its sales dwindled in the US and China, as is evident in the price cut it has implemented there.

SK SINGH, BY MAIL

Banks’ casual attitude

With reference to the editorial, ‘RBI cracks the whip’; private banks usually have a very casual attitude towards instructions of the Reserve Bank of India. Kotak Mahindra Bank was found guilty of deficiencies in its online and digital operating procedures leading to frequent inconvenience to customers. The bank has been asked to stop issuing new credit cards and opening online accounts. The RBI is fully justified in taking such steps to protect the economy as well as the people from digital fraud. This should serve as a lesson to other banks not to indulge in practices which erode the trust of the common man.

ANTHONY HENRIQUES, Mumbai

Political masters of police

Apropos of the article ‘Police accountability beset by myriad challenges’; it is a fact that the police force is tormented by problems that affect its performance. The biggest problem is acqueiscing to the political masters, who force it to violate laws to carry out their unlawful orders. The police force finds itself in a bind and suffers unnecessarily. It earns the wrath of the common man. There is latent frustration in cops that ultimately finds expression in indirect ways. All problems faced by the police need to be studied and resolved. The police should never remain understaffed. Modern techniques of investigation need modern equipment. All efforts should be made to bridge the public-police gap.

SUDESH KUMAR SHARMA, KAPURTHALA

‘Indifferent’ farmers

Refer to the news report ‘Ambala: Farmers’ agitation hits porters, shopkeepers’; it is intriguing and frustrating to learn that the farmers’ agitation has hit the public hard, taking away people’s livelihoods. The protesting farmers are solely acting according to their whims and fancies. They should have taken legal recourse to get their grievance addressed instead of finding ways to inconvenience the public. The Railways must approach the courts to seek immediate intervention to bring much-needed relief to thousands of people affected by the agitation.

KUMAR GUPT, BY MAIL

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Refer to editorial ‘Dire state of schools’; education in Haryana, right from schools to colleges and universities, is in a state of flux. The reasons for this mess are not far to seek. The control of bureaucracy on the education system, its commercialisation and politicisation have doomed it. Most of the schools lack proper infrastructure, and competent and committed teachers. The majority of schoolteachers, appointed on criterion other than merit, lack knowledge of their own subject. In India, the lopsided education system has compelled students to take up rote learning. Education should catalyse the natural growth of cognitive faculty of a student in a rational, conducive and friendly manner.

ANIL BHATIA, Hisar

Misleading advertisements

Refer to the editorial ‘On the SC’s radar’; manufacturers hoodwink people into buying spurious or substandard products by spending huge sums of money on misleading advertisements, roping in celebrities to endorse products. These firms or their advertisers go unchecked by the regulatory authorities, and even if checked, they are hardly penalised. The Supreme Court has rightly pinpointed that the Indian Medical Association should also set its house in order by not recommending expensive medicines of particular brands.

KR BHARTI, SHIMLA

Inheritance tax

Apropos of the news article, ‘Cong firefights Pitroda’s inheritance tax remarks as PM rakes up its ‘loot mantra’; the issue of inheritance tax, which addresses the political fallout of inequality, has gained global currency. Even US President Joe Biden had proposed a wealth tax, but it received a negative response. The comments of Sam Pitroda, chairman of the Indian Overseas Congress, have highlighted the spectre of wealth distribution. Redistribution of wealth through measures such as inheritance and wealth tax will be counter-productive. The only way out is a recalibration of policies that inhibit labour-intensive manufacturing and massive investment in upgrading human resource capital.

MONA SINGH, BY MAIL

Minimise reservation

Refer to the news report, ‘PM opens new front against Cong, says it wants reservation based on religion’; reservation is shrinking the opportunities of talented Indians, resulting in brain drain. Reservation, whether based on religion, caste or creed, should be minimised as a long-term strategy, instead of propagating it further by making it a poll plank to garner votes. The nation can flourish and become self-reliant only if its talented citizens are encouraged to stay in their respective countries and provided with better opportunities so that they are not lured by Western dreams.

RS NARULA, PATIALA

Trust EVMs

With reference to the news report ‘Can’t control poll, hacking of EVMs mere suspicion: SC in VVPAT case’; while hearing a plea for 100 per cent matching of EVM votes with VVPAT slips, the apex court has assured that it will consider issuing directions to strengthen the EVM system. The Supreme Court made it clear that going back to the paper ballot was out of the question and that hacking of EVM machines was mere suspicion. Since there has been no incident of hacking of EVMs so far, all stakeholders need to repose faith in the robust working of the sophisticated machines. Hopefully, the SC directions will satisfy all stakeholders and bring an end to the controversy surrounding EVMs. However, whether political parties will refrain from blaming the EVMs in case of defeat remains to be seen.

RAVI SHARMA, DHARIWAL

Legalise party manifestos

The Lok Sabha elections have brought various political parties on the same platform as all of them claim to be the guardians of democracy. What is the commitment of a political party towards a ‘manifesto’? The Supreme Court must take charge along with the Election Commission of India, by legalising the manifestos. If discrepancies are found, public accountability of a person/group should be fixed and such leaders, after a state-wise assessment, should be barred from contesting elections for at least one term.

HARSIMRANVIR SINGH, PATIALA

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of the editorial ‘Exercise restraint’; in India, religion comes into play to push voters into the mire of divisive politics. People tend to be attracted by flawed ideologies. During electioneering, political leaders should talk about employment, GDP, development, etc. It is not only the leaders who are responsible; it is the public which gets trapped in their jingoism. We all must work towards unity in diversity in the real sense. If politics of hatred and division enters the genes of the younger generation, it would have disastrous consequences.

SANJAY CHOPRA, MOHALI

Medical treatment

Apropos of the news report ‘SC turns heat on IMA: ‘Complaints of unethical conduct, put house in order’; the apex court’s intervention has brought great relief to everybody. The common man is at the receiving end as far as medical treatment is concerned, whether it is allopathic or any other mode of treatment. Doctors, hospitals, pharmaceutical companies and medical laboratories are all in cahoots. Medical treatment is getting unaffordable for many people. Ayurvedic formulations are prepared by concocting ingredients in a hit-and-trial method with exaggerated claims as there is no government authority to cross-check. The entire healthcare system has become a Gordian knot.

YOGINDER SINGHAL, LADWA

Teachers in schools

Refer to ‘19 Haryana schools sans students, 811 make do with lone teacher’; mere talk of GDP growth will not suffice, unless the backbone of the education system is strong. The state government has been regularly conducting examinations for recruiting teachers. What has been the outcome of this exercise? Infrastructure is of no value without teachers in schools. More emphasis needs to be given to fulfilling educational needs of school students. The state and Central governments must take note of these lapses and fill vacancies with capable teachers in all schools on a regular basis as early as possible for the current session.

TARUSHA, KAPURTHALA

Present-day reality

The recent unprecedented floods in Dubai have sparked a much-needed discussion on weather modification and geo-engineering. Theories on what caused the extreme rainfall include cloud seeding, global warming and poor drainage systems. The Arabian Sea is warming up at one of the fastest rates and it poses a significant threat to the western coastline in India, including Maharashtra, Gujarat, Goa, and Kerala. Mumbai, in particular, is extremely vulnerable. Such natural disasters will only become more frequent and severe as global warming intensifies. Their impact on India’s economy and infrastructure cannot be ignored. The deluge in Dubai serves as a stark reminder that the effects of climate change are no longer a distant threat but a present-day reality.

Shruti Saggar, Ludhiana

Instilling trust in every voter

It is the fundamental duty of the Election Commission of India to hold free and fair elections with absolute transparency. If the ECI and the government fail to maintain public trust, the Supreme Court must take cognisance of the matter. The election process takes about a month and a half to be completed. If counting of VVPAT (voter verifiable paper audit trail) slips takes additional time to satisfy the stakeholders, it might exonerate the ECI or the government regarding EVM machines. The common man has a lot of hope from the apex court to nurture democracy.

DILWAR ALI, TOHANA

Role of local communities

With reference to the news report, ‘Warming faster than rest of the world, Asia most disaster-hit’; an indispensable role can be played by the local communities as key stakeholders and agents of change in the fight against climate change. It is a wake-up call for increased recognition and assistance from local communities in Asia, who serve as custodians of indigenous knowledge passed down through generations to mitigate the adverse impact of environmental disruptions.

Nitika, Chandigarh

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

This refers to the editorial ‘health insurance’; it must be kept in mind that most senior citizens who retire from the private sector do not have the resources to pay hefty premiums. To ensure effective use of the facility offered by the IRDAI (Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India), the government must make arrangements to lower the premium amount by way of discontinuing GST on the sum for senior citizens; otherwise, the age concession will be of no use. Balancing compassionate care with fiscal responsibility will safeguard both patients and insurers.

CHANDER SHEKHAR SHARMA, Mohali

No overreaction on Muizzu’s win

Apropos the editorial ‘Maldivian elections’; President Mohamed Muizzu had campaigned on the ‘India out’ theme and his government had asked for the minuscule number of Indian troops in the country to be withdrawn. Muizzu drew Male closer to Beijing by giving contracts for infrastructure projects. The Indian government has done well not to overreact to his party’s win and made an attempt to distance Male from New Delhi with a pragmatic approach. Delhi must, of course, draw the line on matters that undermine its security and core interests.

SS PAUL, Nadia

Private investment in sports

With reference to the news report ‘Right move, Gukesh becomes youngest to contest world title’; Gukesh has shown that not only does he possess exceptional talent but also has a mature head on his shoulders. Since the beginning of 2024, the world’s top-ranked players have included Viswanathan Anand, Gukesh, Praggnanandhaa, Arjun Erigaisi and Vidit Gujrathi, which is testimony to the amazing chess talent in our country. The chess ecosystem in India is flourishing at a rapid pace, with young players from tier 2 and 3 cities playing really well. Private investment in any sport helps it to grow, and Tech Mahindra becoming a joint venture partner in the Global Chess League is a welcome step.

BAL GOVIND, Noida

Insult to democracy

With reference to the news report ‘Mohinder Singh Kaypee third party-hopper to enter Jalandhar battle arena’; this opportunism is disgusting. Defection is an insult to the sacrifices of our freedom fighters and the people who lost their lives in the struggle for Independence. They fought to end the oppression of foreign rulers with a hope that they would achieve democracy where people would elect trustworthy leaders. When power-hungry leaders switch sides to other parties for personal gains, people feel cheated and democracy becomes a laughing stock.

FAQIR SINGH, Dasuya

Election rhetoric

Refer to the news report ‘PM doubles down on anti-Cong pitch, claims it will seize, redistribute wealth’; election campaigns by political parties are justified, but only when they are fair and not polarising in nature. India does not need rhetoric from any party on the distribution of wealth. Once such links are made, the narrative around them can acquire a life of its own, far removed from the real issues. It is, however, true that the benefits of India’s brisk growth have been unevenly distributed under the rule of the Congress as well as the BJP. Adequate industrial jobs were not created. So, the shift from farm to factories on the scale required did not happen. This is the reason every political party is relying on offering welfare schemes to entice voters.

SATWANT KAUR PANESAR, by mail

EC’s litmus test

The opinion polls of the first phase of polling have not exactly gone in favour of the BJP. In recent days, PM Modi has raised his pitch against the Congress. His remarks border on hate speech if one considers the guidelines laid down by the Election Commission. The Congress has rightly taken the matter to the poll panel. Uddhav Thackeray was sent a notice on using words like ‘Jai Bhawani’ in his party’s anthem, whereas when PM Modi urged people of Karnataka to say ‘Jai Bajrangbali’ while casting their vote, it was overlooked. In fact, it is a litmus test for the Election Commission to exhibit impartiality.

YASH KHETARPAL, PANCHKULA

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit.

These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

With reference to the article ‘Congress, BJP manifestos a damp squib for the health sector’; it rightly lays bare the neglect of healthcare by political parties in India. The focus should be on strengthening public healthcare rather than taking the health insurance route because insurance schemes are being used by the government as a medium to hand over public funds to the private sector. There is no concrete evidence on the effectiveness of public health insurance schemes, and the track record of insurance schemes in the past decade has revealed increased fraudulent implementation, over-investigation, over-prescription, over-diagnosis and irrational treatment.

Vitull K Gupta, Bathinda

Insurance cover for the old

With reference to the news report, ‘IRDAI does away with age cap, those above 65 can now buy new health cover’; the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) has offered adequate protection from healthcare expenses to senior citizens and super-senior citizens by removing the age limit of 65 for individuals buying health insurance policies. Insurers have also been mandated to offer health policies to persons with pre-existing medical conditions. Persons above 60 years are more vulnerable to age-related diseases but have limited sources of income.

UPENDRA SHARMA, by mail

Can’t replace Constitution

Refer to the news report ‘Hemant Soren held for refusing to quit INDIA: Congress at bloc’s unity show’; during the rally organised by Opposition parties at Ranchi, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge said: “The Modi-Shah government will scrap the Constitution if it returns. Democracy will end.” His fear is unfounded. During the Emergency, the Congress government tried to drastically change the Constitution through the 42nd amendment, but the same was declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court in Minerva Mills vs Union of India. In that case, the court propounded the ‘basic structure doctrine’. The SC ruled that the power of Parliament to amend the Constitution was limited. Parliament cannot exercise this limited power to grant itself unfettered powers.

VINAY KUMAR MALHOTRA, AMBALA CANTT

Hope for democracy

The Election Commission’s decision to hold repolling at 11 polling stations in Manipur is not just a routine move; it is a beacon of hope for democracy in a state marred by violence and electoral malpractices. The people of Manipur have bravely defied threats and violence to exercise their democratic right, only to be met with chaos and manipulation. As the world’s largest democracy, India must set an example of integrity and fairness. All eyes are on Manipur — the authorities must conduct the elections with transparency and accountability.

GAGANPREET SINGH, Mohali

UGC’s encouraging steps

The University Grants Commission (UGC) is making every effort for higher enrolment of scholars in PhD courses. The recent changes introduced by the UGC are welcome. A lot of Indian scholars rush to foreign universities to grab quality stipend for research with easy admission there. Earlier, it was difficult to pursue PhD from government-approved colleges. After the easing of norms, we are hopeful that more and more Indian researchers will get enrolled in PhD studies. Such encouraging efforts will surely bring positive changes in the Indian academic system.

KIRTI WADHAWAN, KANPUR

Religious bodies must be taxed

Regarding the editorial ‘Yoga fee taxable’; the apex court’s verdict has been aptly endorsed. Financial transactions involving religious or political institutions should be subject to taxation. This measure would promote equity and accountability in the domain of service taxation. Considering the vast, untaxed funds collected by these institutions, they are often alleged to be misused for political gains.

BALVINDER, CHANDIGARH

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of ‘Congress slow off the blocks’ (Nous Indica); the author aptly says that ideology does not matter much to the voters. They vote on grounds such as caste, community, candidate’s stature and image. Timely distribution of tickets and stitching of alliances with like-minded parties are among the factors that send out a strong message to the electorate. Any delay on these counts could cost any party dear. These winnable parameters are not conspicuously visible in the Congress, compared to its mighty rival, the BJP. The grand old party needs a charismatic leader like Indira Gandhi.

RAVI SHARMA, Dhariwal

Focus where BJP lacks

Refer to ‘Congress slow off the blocks’ (Nous Indica); despite PM Modi’s guarantees, many promises made by the BJP have remained unfulfilled. This is the time for the Congress and the INDIA bloc to lay stress on the areas in which the BJP appears to be on a sticky wicket and not let go the chance at any cost. The Congress is moving at a slow pace in every respect. Neither has it mobilised workers at the grassroots level nor is it doing enough to keep its flock together. Infighting in the Congress is affecting the announcement of candidates.

RAJ KUMAR KAPOOR, ROPAR

Too expensive proposal

With reference to a recent report, ‘30 IAF bases to get 5-layer security system’, do we really need such an elaborate security system that includes sensors, thermal cameras, radar and underground vibration detection system? No airbase anywhere in the world has this kind of a security system. Besides, no system, howsoever sophisticated, can be foolproof. The Pathankot airbase attack in 2016, that had triggered this proposal, was an isolated instance which doesn’t call for an overreaction. The proposed five-layer security system would be too expensive. While no compromise should be made on security, the proposal should be cost-effective. After the Pathankot attack, a high-level committee was constituted to suggest remedial measures. Several recommendations were implemented. Nothing more is perhaps needed.

WG CDR CL SEHGAL (RETD), JALANDHAR

Focus on health, not taste

Refers to editorial ‘Cut sugar & salt’; the aim of business houses like Cadbury, Nestle and IndiGo should be to provide nutritious food to consumers so that they remain healthy and their wellbeing is not affected. The sole aim should not be to make the product tasty and attractive. All FMCG (fast-moving consumer goods) companies should stress on healthy ingredients and products. They should strictly adhere to self-regulation. The government should ensure that all food processing units comply with the standards and norms laid down by experts. Occasionally, surprise checks to monitor products should be carried out to keep the manufacturers on their toes.

SUBHASH VAID, New Delhi

Ballot paper more reliable

Refer to the news report ‘Mustn’t skip voting, CJI urges electorate’; it is fine that all eligible people must vote. However, the alleged vulnerability of EVMs (electronic voting machines) remains a grey area. Before the advent of EVMs, voting by ballot paper used to be safe and secure. The ballot method is being used by many nations across the world, though it is time-consuming due to physical counting of votes. The government should either bring back ballot paper voting or make EVM functioning totally transparent.

ROOP SINGH NEGI, Solan

UNSC seat for India

Refer to the news report ‘Support reforms: US official on Musk’s remark on permanent UNSC seat for India’; Elon Musk has rightly said it is absurd that a permanent UNSC seat has eluded India so far. India, the most populous country of the world, deserves this seat. The UNSC’s five members with veto power are out of touch with the present-day geopolitical realities. India’s growing importance is acknowledged by international platforms such as G20, Quad, I2U2 and the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation.

LAL SINGH, AMRITSAR

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

The editorial ‘Haryana hospitals’ reflects the sad state of affairs. Staff shortage, a short supply of medicines and inoperative hospitals add to the patients’ woes. So many patients battling serious health issues have to endure a long wait. They often don’t even get proper treatment, and occasionally, they bear the brunt of medical negligence. Even those suffering from chronic and infectious diseases fail to get timely treatment at times. Addressing the lapses in healthcare provisions and the management of funds allotted for healthcare need a comprehensive approach. It is crucial to ensuring quality care for all patients.

Priyanka, Amritsar

Ensure enforcement of laws

Refer to the article ‘Need to review functioning of food & drug regulatory agencies’; there are innumerable companies and clinics promoting herbal medicines for the treatment of arthritis, psoriasis, etc, on TV. Many ointments and creams are also being advertised for various skin disorders and the ‘enhancement of beauty’. Celebrities advertising pan masala is very unfortunate. Further, it is a matter of concern that roadside eateries and food joints selling adulterated and unhygienic items have been mushrooming in the country. The onus is on food and drug regulatory agencies to ensure that customers or consumers are not sold any harmful product. The implementation of the existing laws should not be lax.

O Prasada Rao, Hyderabad

Monitor advertisements

With reference to the article ‘Need to review functioning of food & drug regulatory agencies’; the author has rightly called for the strict enforcement of the laws to rein in misleading advertisements related to drugs, remedies, health products and food supplements. The authorities concerned need to take a serious view of violations and help save the common man from falling prey to unethical marketing strategies. Besides, the publication and telecast of advertisements needs to be properly monitored. A consumer’s health or safety must not be played with.

Vijay Laxmi, Amritsar

Protesting farmers disrupt trains

Refer to the report ‘No let-up in farmers’ protest, 61 trains cancelled, 64 diverted’; the cultivators from Punjab and Haryana are not wrong to push for their demands. However, squatting on railway tracks and disrupting rail traffic is not the right way to protest. Many passengers were inconvenienced as several trains were cancelled and others diverted because of the agitation. Sadly, farmers in the region have turned into troublemakers. Nevertheless, the authorities concerned must take into consideration the legitimate demands of the cultivators. But the tillers should also be more responsible and call off the stir at the Shambhu railway station.

Krishan Kant Sood, Nangal

A humane solution to dog menace

The mauling of a man by a pack of stray dogs in a Nabha village is shocking. Cases of dog bite have long been common, but someone being mauled to death is a rarity. Despite a spate of dog attacks on residents every year, the authorities concerned have taken no concrete step to tackle the menace, showing complete disregard for human life. Civic bodies have failed to carry out sterilisation of stray canines to check their population. It is the scarcity of food that may be prompting dogs to turn aggressive and attack humans. The government must set aside funds to arrange food, shelter and treatment for stray dogs.

Col RS Narula (retd), Patiala

Don’t entertain frivolous pleas

Apropos of the news report ‘SC reserves verdict on EVM-VVPAT tallying, says can’t suspect everything’; such pleas are often driven by unwarranted fears and vested interests. These cases are a big drain on the resources of constitutional courts. Dismissing such cases or allowing the withdrawal of frivolous petitions is sometimes not enough. Courts would do well, as a rule, to impose heavy costs on the petitioners to dissuade them from making a mockery of the judiciary so that the focus remains on serious disputes. No court should entertain a plea on insignificant matters.

Lalit Bharadwaj, Panchkula

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

With reference to the editorial ‘Mob violence’; the rise in incidents of cow vigilantism is alarming. The killing of two Rajasthan residents, Nasir and Junaid, on the suspicion of cattle smuggling last year was symptomatic of the growing menace. As the cow is considered a sacred animal in Hinduism, Hindu nationalists often take it upon themselves to act as the protectors of the milch animal. But over the years, vigilantes in states like Haryana and Rajasthan have taken advantage of the cause and extorted money from cattle smugglers in exchange for letting them pass through their areas. States must work together to curb the menace. Also, members of the Muslim community must respect the sentiments of Hindus and desist from slaughtering cows.

Krishan Bhatia, Hansi

Naxalite shadow on polls

Apropos of the editorial ‘Bastar encounter’; the District Reserve Guard and Border Security Force personnel deserve kudos for the daring act of killing 29 Maoists, including history-sheeter Shankar Rao. The huge recovery of arms and ammunition from the area is concerning. There should be no compromise on security measures as the threat of Naxal activities persists. They are able to carry out major attacks because of their strong intelligence-gathering capacity and the support they receive from local residents. As India goes to the polls, the government must take steps to ensure the safety of voters and the smooth conduct of the electoral process, especially in regions prone to Naxalite violence.

Gregory Fernandes, Mumbai

Failure of healthcare system

Refer to the editorial ‘Ailing healthcare’; the harrowing incident at the Ludhiana Civil Hospital exposes a chilling reality of neglect and disregard for human dignity. The fact that a patient was forced to share a bed with a corpse is not just a failure of the healthcare system but a moral travesty. The lack of basic medical attention for days, coupled with bureaucratic apathy, highlights systemic inadequacies that cannot be excused. As the victim’s suffering persisted, administrative formalities took precedence over urgent medical care. The case serves as a distressing reminder of the dire state of our healthcare system, where individuals are reduced to mere numbers. Swift and decisive action must be taken to ensure that such egregious lapses never recur and that all patients receive the care and respect they deserve.

Gurdev Singh, Mohali

Public healthcare long neglected

With reference to the article ‘Reduce out-of-pocket expenditure to revitalise healthcare’; the author has rightly stressed the need for reducing such expenses. Public healthcare has long been neglected by successive governments. India has failed to address health problems like anaemia, malnutrition and obesity and issues like a lack of safe drinking water. Besides, it seems like insurance schemes are being used by the government as a medium to hand over public funds to the private sector. India needs to change its priorities to boost essential public services, such as health, education and infrastructure, and develop a system under which corporates and public institutions work together to ensure equitable growth.

Vitull K Gupta, Bathinda

Residents’ safety gone to the dogs

Apropos of the news report ‘Man mauled by stray dogs, third death in two months in Patiala district’; the menace of dog attacks is not confined to any particular region. Such cases are reported from time to time throughout the state. For how long will the authorities concerned let helpless residents be bitten or mauled by canines? The Punjab Government must come up with a solid action plan to eradicate the growing problem. Besides, there is a need to ensure the timely release of adequate compensation to the victims of dog attacks or their families.

Jagdish Chander, Jalandhar

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Refer to the editorial ‘Resilient Rushdie’; the Mumbai-born author has remained a strong votary of free speech despite the near-fatal attack on him in August 2022. His life had long been under threat since the publication of his controversial novel, The Satanic Verses. Rushdie’s resilience and defiance in the face of a looming threat to his life are commendable. Religion is such a sensitive issue that communal violence erupts the moment any dissenting view is expressed. Free discourse on religious matters must not be prohibited. Freedom of thought, even on religious matters, is as necessary as political or socio-economic liberty.

Roshan Lal Goel, Ladwa

The right to be offensive

With reference to the editorial ‘Resilient Rushdie’; the freedom to dissent is the bedrock of a flourishing culture. With his new memoir reflecting on the 2022 knife attack on him, the fearless writer has once again risen and stood up for his right to freedom of expression. In an age of increasing censorship and attacks on creative freedom, Rushdie’s return is a reminder that the right to express oneself, even if it involves provoking or offending some sections of society, is the cornerstone of democracy.

SK Singh, by mail

Ensure wellbeing of patients

Refer to the editorial ‘Ailing healthcare’; forcing a patient to share a bed with a corpse reflects the highly irresponsible and callous attitude of the Ludhiana Civil Hospital authorities toward the wellbeing of patients. The incident needs to be looked into. Adequate facilities and infrastructure at hospitals, the establishment of new medical colleges and nursing institutes and the contribution of the pharma industry to ensure the availability of essential medicines at affordable prices are the need of the hour. It is important to remember that healthy citizens are the real wealth of a country.

Subhash Vaid, New Delhi

Conduct checks at hospitals

Apropos of the editorial ‘Ailing healthcare’; the Punjab Government makes tall claims about providing better healthcare facilities to residents, but such incidents reflect poorly on it. A distressing incident like this can erode public trust in the system. While the state government has announced a hike in the healthcare budget and proposed initiatives like the establishment of new medical colleges and mohalla clinics to provide medical facilities to patients at their doorstep, the shortage of doctors and a lack of medicines and other facilities have left the healthcare system ailing. Regular reporting, monitoring, surprise checks and audits at health facilities can help address the issue.

NK Gosain, Bathinda

Don’t discredit AAP govt’s efforts

Refer to the editorial ‘Ailing healthcare’; the episode is just an isolated case that should not be used to discredit the efforts made by the AAP-led state government to revolutionise the health sector. So many mohalla clinics have been opened in Punjab to ensure that residents have easy access to services. There is no doubt that the government should take a serious view of the incident at the Ludhiana hospital. But the government should not be blamed for it. Let us not forget how, in 2022, Punjab CM Bhagwant Mann sacked the state’s then health minister, Vijay Singla, over allegations of corruption. That shows the AAP government’s commitment to good governance.

BM Singh, Amritsar

Voters’ time to decide

With reference to the article ‘The winnability factor and the failure of NOTA’; for a vibrant democracy, it is important for the electorate to vote to power a candidate who is honest, capable and known for his commitment to public welfare. If no candidate in the fray meets the standards set by the electorate, it would not be wrong for the voters to go for the ‘NOTA’ option. With the General Election around the corner, the ball is in the voters’ court. They can decide if they want to have a clean candidate in power or one with criminal antecedents.

MD Sharma, Shimla

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of the editorial ‘BJP manifesto’; amid the din of polls, the BJP is counting the promises it made in its last manifesto that it has fulfilled. The Ram Mandir has been consecrated, and the CAA is being implemented. But how does any of it help the common man? It can be said that the construction of the Ram Mandir in Ayodhya has helped the party secure the Hindu vote bank. But it does not solve issues like unemployment, price rise and corruption. Besides, the saffron party’s election campaign has gone off track. PM Narendra Modi’s remarks on Opposition leaders having meat during the month of Sawan and accusing them of having a ‘Mughal mindset’ reflect badly on him.

Yash Khetarpal, Panchkula

Don’t play with consumers’ health

Refer to the editorial ‘No, it’s not healthy’; the fact that thousands of firms are allowed to market their products with misleading labelling in the absence of proper checks is a matter of serious concern. No product that can be injurious to health should be allowed in the market, and at least not with the tag of being healthy. Successive governments have shown a lack of courage and political will to look into the matter. The quality, quantity and effects of every ingredient in a product should be analysed. It is also necessary to punish the authorities concerned for their inaction.

AG Rajmohan, Anantapur (AP)

Probe agencies shouldn’t have bias

With reference to the news report ‘Only 3% ED cases against politicians, honest have nothing to fear: PM Modi’; PM Narendra Modi is right in a way. The people of India would want to see those guilty of corruption brought to book. But it is worrisome how some ‘tainted’ Opposition leaders get a clean chit after crossing over to the ruling party. It sends the wrong message to people across the country. Probe agencies must act against all politicians involved in graft, irrespective of their political affiliation. The ED, the CBI and other agencies must have no bias.

Roop Singh Negi, Solan

True happiness is unattainable

Refer to the article ‘The grand myth of absolute happiness’; complete happiness is unattainable in reality, as human experiences are inherently dynamic and subject to change, and no individual can achieve perpetual bliss. While societal factors like economic security contribute to contentment, systemic inequalities hinder true happiness. And hence, absolute happiness remains elusive. So, people should instead strive for a balanced and meaningful existence grounded in inner peace. By embracing life’s complexities and finding joy in simplicity, one can transcend the illusion of absolute happiness and cultivate genuine fulfilment.

Chanchal S Mann, Una

Rat race robs people of joy

With reference to the article ‘The grand myth of absolute happiness’; the fast pace of life, the rat race and the focus on material possessions have robbed the masses of joy. In the rush to get admission at reputable institutions and to land a job with a good salary, true happiness has been lost. What is the point of having plenty of money and a rich lifestyle if one is not truly happy? True happiness lies in contentment with what one already has. It is something that owning material items cannot buy.

Abhilasha Gupta, Mohali

Negligence at govt hospitals

Apropos of the news report ‘Patient shares bed with corpse at Ludhiana Civil Hospital’; the state of medical facilities at the hospital in question is shocking. It reflects poorly on the hospital management and highlights the callous attitude of the doctors there. Health professionals serving at government hospitals often have a cavalier attitude because they enjoy job stability. It is time to revisit the policies regarding the recruitment and employment of doctors at government health facilities. That may push medical professionals to be more professional and prevent such an administrative lapse.

RS Narula, Patiala

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of the editorial ‘Iran vs Israel’; the retaliatory attack by Iran on Israel is not just a local conflict but a harbinger of a broader regional crisis. With hundreds of drones and missiles launched, innocent lives remain at risk. The escalating tensions threaten to engulf West Asia into a devastating war. The onus is on world leaders to swiftly coordinate a diplomatic response to prevent further escalation. The US’ backing for Israel must be balanced with efforts to de-escalate the situation and prevent a wider conflict. It is imperative for the UN Security Council to condemn Tehran's actions and find a path towards peace. The stakes are too high to not act.

Gurdev Singh, Mohali

World can’t afford a bigger conflict

Refer to the editorial ‘Iran vs Israel’; the drone and missile attack by Iran on Israel late on Saturday night has sparked fears of the six-month-old Israel-Hamas war spilling over. The big question now is: How will Israel respond to the attack? Iran has described its move as an act of self-defence and just a response to the attack on its consulate in Damascus. Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu, on the other hand, has warned: “Whoever harms us, we will harm them”. It is very unlikely that Israel will take the attack lying down. But it would be in the best interest of the world to ensure a de-escalation of the situation. The world has already been reeling from two wars, and it cannot afford a bigger conflict in West Asia.

RK Arora, Mohali

Choose diplomacy, not conflict

With reference to ‘Iran vs Israel’; the Iranian assault on Israel marks a perilous escalation, threatening to engulf the region in a bigger conflict. America’s unwavering support for Israel, while commendable, underscores the complexity of international alliances and the delicate balance of power. More needs to be done to address the underlying tensions. The threat of a response from Israel is looming. Iran’s declaration of the conclusion of the matter, juxtaposed with its stern warning against further Israeli actions, paints a picture of a conflict paused but not resolved. In this precarious moment, the international community must prioritise diplomacy over aggression. The alternative — a regional war with untold consequences — cannot be accepted.

Sahibpreet Singh, Mohali

Caution thrown to the wind

Refer to the news report ‘550 Rewari school buses unfit or sans permit; 345 impounded’; it is astonishing that such a huge number of school buses plying on roads in Rewari district lack permits. It is a matter of shame that it took the loss of six lives for the authorities to wake up from slumber. The school authorities and the district officials are to blame for the Mahendragarh mishap. Stringent punishment should be given to them. Further, the government should issue guidelines to all schools to ensure compliance with the safety norms. Besides, other states should also take steps to avoid such tragedies, as the issue is not just limited to Haryana.

Raj Kumar Kapoor, Ropar

Hope for J&K residents

Apropos of the editorial ‘PM's J&K outreach’; the restoration of the statehood of J&K and the conduct of Assembly elections in the UT are two significant promises made by the PM that inspire confidence. The political atmosphere in J&K has long been volatile. If the PM keeps the promises, it could help foster development and prosperity in the region. But there is a need to outline a roadmap and set a timeframe for the milestones to be achieved. That is the only way to ensure that the aspirations of the people of the Valley are realised.

DV Sharma, Mukerian

The Kargil lessons

Refer to the article ‘A saga of bravery, discipline & sacrifice’; the Army operation was well planned and ably executed, but Kargil was a glaring case of intelligence failure. India needs to improve its intelligence-gathering system. The writer, who was a part of the Kargil operation, has rightly lauded the bravery of the troops and the sacrifice made by them. But let us not forget the role played by the Indian Air Force in the war.

WG CDR CL Sehgal (retd), Jalandhar

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of ‘Shadow of economic distress on polls’ (Nous Indica); unemployment and price rise can influence the outcome of the Lok Sabha elections. The amelioration of the suffering of poor and marginalised people is the real parameter of a country’s progress. It is generally the poor who bear the brunt of price rise. Employment provides financial independence to people, enabling them to lead a prosperous and meaningful life. The ruling party, however, has been micromanaging its election campaign, making course correction in its electoral strategy, stitching up alliances with regional parties and banking on pro-poor welfare initiatives. It remains to be seen if the saffron party will be able to overcome the challenge and win the elections.

Ravi Sharma, Dhariwal

Fate of BJP sealed

With reference to ‘Shadow of economic distress on polls’ (Nous Indica); the fast-changing political scenario in our country indicates that a landslide victory for the BJP in the General Election is not a foregone conclusion, contrary to what some sections of the media are suggesting. The BJP relies on identity politics, pivoting around matters like the Ram Temple, and welfare schemes for the poor. But it may not be enough to offset the damage caused by the economic distress. The huge scale of unemployment and soaring prices of essential items are a matter of concern. Economic distress may override any other consideration in sealing the fate of the BJP in the Lok Sabha elections.

Roshan Lal Goel, by mail

Create jobs to tackle distress

Refer to ‘Shadow of economic distress on polls’; the author has rightly highlighted issues of unemployment and price rise. The numerous welfare schemes launched by the ruling dispensation may have impacted the poor positively, but they are not enough to uplift those who don’t have jobs. Employment generation is the best way to tackle economic distress. No matter how good a political party’s poll strategy is, it cannot bring on board unemployed voters unless they are given hope for a job.

Hari Krishan Chaudhary, Mohali

Ensure safety of students

Apropos of the editorial ‘School bus mishap’; the accident that claimed the lives of six schoolkids and injured many others is a result of gross negligence and dereliction of duty on the part of the bus driver, the school management, district education officials and traffic police personnel. The episode is a reminder of the importance of ensuring adherence to safety norms. It is unfortunate that the government only wakes up when an untoward incident occurs. District officials must conduct safety audits at schools from time to time. All school bus drivers must be made to take breathalyser tests regularly. More needs to be done to ensure the safety of students.

NK Gosain, Bathinda

Negligence claims precious lives

With reference to the editorial ‘School bus mishap’; the death of six students in the Mahendragarh bus accident has left the parents in a state of shock. Precious lives were lost, all because of the recklessness of a drunk driver. Most private schools charge parents thousands of rupees as transportation fee. It is incumbent on the school authorities to engage only well-trained drivers and ensure that no unfit buses are used. The safety of the pupils must remain the top priority of the authorities. The officials concerned must take steps to prevent a repeat of the incident.

Raj Bahadur Yadav, Fatehabad

Hold school mgmt accountable

Refer to ‘School bus mishap’; it was not the first such incident, and unfortunately, it would not be the last. Whenever such a tragedy happens, there is a hue and cry for some days, and then it all blows over. But hopefully, this horrific crash will wake the authorities concerned from slumber. No monetary compensation can mitigate the agony of the parents who have lost their children. Exemplary punishment should be given to the school management and all local or state-level authorities responsible for the mishap. They must change their attitude and start ensuring compliance with the safety guidelines.

Bhupinder Kochhar, Panchkula

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of the editorial ‘Safeguard students’; the fact that the incident occurred at an educational institution in Punjab is shameful and shocking. It brings forth the vulnerability of girls and women. Despite all the talk of women’s empowerment, girls are not even safe on the premises of an educational institution. It is a sad commentary on the collective failure of the institution, administration and society as a whole to check crimes against women. Besides, whenever such an untoward incident happens, instead of ensuring justice for the victims, school or college authorities rush to hush up the matter to protect the reputation of the institution. A zero-tolerance approach to sexual harassment and exemplary punishment for the guilty must be ensured to curb such heinous crimes.

Priyanka, by mail

Enhance security at institutions

With reference to the editorial ‘Safeguard students’; it is not an isolated incident. Such cases point to a broader systemic failure that should be looked into. The absence of CCTV cameras and lax security arrangements that allow outsiders easy access to the premises demonstrate negligence on the part of the authorities. College authorities, local law enforcement officials and policymakers need to view this incident not merely as a crime but as a clear indicator of the system’s inadequacies. There is an urgent need to step up the security measures at all institutions. Much needs to be done to transform educational campuses into sanctuaries of learning and personal growth, not arenas of fear and crime. 

Amity Gumber, Abohar

Integrated theatre commands

Apropos of the article ‘The knotty issues delaying integrated theatre commands’; the delay in establishing integrated theatre commands is a disservice to our nation’s security. Leaders must address this matter on priority. The lack of coordination among our armed forces leaves us vulnerable to unforeseen threats. In an era of rapid global shifts, unity and efficiency are non-negotiable. Our military must evolve to meet contemporary challenges. The establishment of integrated theatre commands is not just a strategic necessity but a moral imperative to safeguard India’s sovereignty. Bureaucracy or red tape must not hinder progress.

Gaganpreet Singh, Mohali

Canadian clean chit to India

Refer to the report ‘No evidence of India’s interference in poll: Canadian probe clears air’; a Canadian panel has cleared India of interference claims. In a testimony before the panel, former Deputy Foreign Minister Marta Morgan clarified that there was no trace of Indian disinformation in the Canadian information ecosystem. Former Cabinet Secretary Janice Charette stated that the Indian Government did not meddle in the 2021 Canadian election. Ottawa should not have accused New Delhi of influencing its elections. PM Justin Trudeau must tender an unconditional apology to India.

Upendra Sharma, by mail

Another road mishap

With reference to the news report ‘6 schoolkids die in Haryana mishap’; private schools often use old buses for the transportation of children. Many such buses are operated without the necessary clearances, pollution certificates, valid documents or trained drivers. The tragedy is a grim reminder that nothing concrete has been done to prevent such accidents. The incident should be probed thoroughly. Financial assistance to the bereaved families is not enough. It is easy for most members of the public to move on from the tragedy until another mishap occurs. It is time that the authorities concerned are held accountable for it.

Wg Cdr JS Minhas (retd), Mohali

A breath of fresh air

Refer to the article ‘Hope for a change of heart’; new NIA Director General Sadanand Date’s dedication to truth and justice is commendable. However, it is concerning that many of the nation’s bureaucrats place personal gains above constitutional integrity. This is why young voters lose faith in the system and the electoral process. The trend of the pardoning of sins of Opposition leaders who join the ruling party is a glaring violation of electoral ethics. The need of the hour is for our leaders and bureaucrats to heed the call of their conscience and perform their duties with honesty.

Chanchal S Mann, Una

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit.

These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

With reference to the editorial ‘Indian students in peril’; the death of yet another Indian student in the US is a matter of concern. It calls for effective steps to rein in racially motivated crimes and anti-social activities. The Indian-origin students in America must be assured of their safety. Such incidents need to be thoroughly investigated to determine the root cause, and the perpetrators should be dealt with sternly. US Ambassador to India Eric Garcetti’s assertion that his government is ‘very committed’ to making Indians realise that America is a safe place to study will ring hollow if such criminal activities are not curbed on priority.

Ravi Sharma, Dhariwal

Check anti-Indian propaganda

Refer to ‘Indian students in peril’; the recent spate of deaths of Indian students in the US has sparked concerns about the safety of members of the Indian diaspora there. Many young Indians migrate to countries like the US, the land of opportunities, for higher education. Some of them face racial discrimination or become targets of hate crime. There is a need to counter the negative propaganda against the Indian community in the West, leading to racially motivated attacks on innocent Indians. It is unfortunate that American laws often fail to protect the interests of the victims of such attacks and their families. 

Gregory Fernandes, Mumbai

Protection from climate crisis

Apropos of ‘Climate change’; the verdict given by the European Court of Human Rights affirming protection from the impact of climate change as a human right is historic. India’s Supreme Court has also stressed that citizens have a right to be shielded from the detrimental effects of the crisis. This will encourage activists to hold governments accountable for all types of environmental disasters, ranging from floods to droughts. Nations should make joint efforts to limit global warming. More needs to be done to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. There are critical gaps in the environmental sustainability policies being followed by several nations. The recent legal victories can help deliver justice to billions of people affected by natural disasters.

Gaurav Kochhar, Yamunanagar

Hit the brakes on speeding

With reference to the news report ‘Bathinda schoolboy crashes speeding car into tree, killed’; the boy’s parents are to blame for the incident. No parent should allow their underage wards to drive cars. The youngster, who was reportedly obsessed with speed, had posted videos showing his car being driven around 160-180 km per hour. He was driving the car at a breakneck speed, and it ultimately ended in his death. The traffic police need to do more to check the menace of rash driving before it claims more lives. Any person crossing the speed limits must receive strict punishment.

Bir Devinder Singh Bedi, Sangrur

Parents’ negligence costs life

Refer to the report ‘Bathinda schoolboy crashes speeding car into tree, killed’; the youngster could have hit pedestrians with his car, injuring or killing them. He could have also crashed into a bigger vehicle, like a bus or truck, embroiling the driver in a legal case without any fault on the latter’s part. It is telling that the deceased was a minor. The incident was a direct outcome of gross negligence on the part of his parents. In such cases, legal action must be taken against the parents. They must not be spared.

Ravinder Mittal, by mail

A fatal obsession

Apropos of ‘Bathinda schoolboy crashes speeding car into tree, killed’; the death of Uday Partap Singh, a 16-year-old student of Class XI, is tragic. It has come to light that the teenager had posted videos that showed him driving his car around at a speed of 160-180 km per hour. The boy’s parents and the traffic police personnel are to blame for the tragedy. Besides, it was not an isolated incident of overspeeding. Such cases involving youngsters have occurred in the past. It is time for the authorities concerned and parents to make efforts to help youngsters get over their obsession with speed.

Vijaya Sharma, by mail

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of the editorial ‘Disaster relief delay’; India is a country that faces calamities like landslides, floods, cloudbursts, cyclones and droughts every year. Such disasters wreak havoc on entire communities, claiming lives and destroying property. Tamil Nadu is right to ask the apex court to direct the Centre to pay Rs 37,902 crore for the damage caused by Cyclone Michaung and another Rs 2,000 crore as an interim measure for relief operations. Political wrangling and red tape must not come in the way of relief work. The priority of the government should be providing aid to the people in distress. The wellbeing and welfare of the citizens are what really matter.

Subhash Vaid, New Delhi

Frequent defections in politics

It is intriguing that Birender Singh and his wife, Prem Lata, have quit the BJP and rejoined the Congress. This comes just a month after their son, Brijendra Singh, joined the grand old party. Birender had served as a minister in PM Narendra Modi’s cabinet; his son got elected as the Hisar MP on the BJP ticket; and his wife was an MLA. It is clear that Birender was still not content and deserted the BJP for the Congress in search of greener pastures. Politicians are focused on gaining power, and that attitude is to blame for frequent defections. This only puts off voters. 

Ramesh Gupta, Narwana

Kejriwal must mend his ways

Apropos of the news report ‘Enough material: Delhi HC rejects Kejriwal’s plea against arrest by ED’; the Delhi High Court has rightly rejected the AAP national convener’s petition challenging his arrest by the probe agency. The court also dismissed his allegation of political vendetta on the eve of the Lok Sabha elections. The HC’s rebuke of Kejriwal for ‘casting aspersions’ on the judicial process with his claim about an approver in a money laundering case making donations to the BJP via electoral bonds is welcome. The CM must shun the use of such tactics.

Upendra Sharma, by mail

A victim of political vendetta

The Delhi HC’s rejection of Arvind Kejriwal’s plea challenging his arrest in the graft case is disappointing. It not only undermines the principle of justice but also raises concerns about the impartiality of our legal system. Kejriwal’s arrest, just ahead of the General Election, reeks of political vendetta and is not a genuine pursuit of justice. The Supreme Court must intervene to ensure that our leaders, regardless of their political affiliations, are treated fairly. The allegations of ‘tax terrorism’ and politically motivated investigations further highlight the urgent need for accountability and transparency in governance.

Sahibpreet Singh, Mohali

Systemic failure to rein in crimes

Refer to the article ‘Systemic changes a must to curb fake encounters’; the problem of fake encounters is assuming alarming proportions in India. Often, the cops who carry out fake encounters, generally under pressure from those in power, are treated as heroes. Politicians perceived as having a hand in such encounters also reap electoral dividends. Besides, the officials involved in fake encounters are seldom brought to book. There is no excuse for breaking the law, not even when it is broken to take out anti-social elements. Such cases are an outcome of the systemic failure of the law enforcement agencies to tackle crimes and the inability of the judicial system to deliver justice in time.

Roshan Lal Goel, Ladwa

Glorifying extrajudicial killings

With reference to ‘Systemic changes a must to curb fake encounters’; the pop culture and movies are to blame for romanticising extrajudicial killings. Influenced by cinema, many citizens have started celebrating such encounters, which are now common in states like Uttar Pradesh. The due process of law is a long and exhausting one, and it involves a lot of effort on the part of the police to have a culprit convicted. The idea of the state spending so much money on the confinement of criminals does not sit well with many well-meaning people. And that is what prompts the authorities and police officials to take the law into their own hands.

Anthony Henriques, Mumbai

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit.

These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

With reference to the editorial ‘Battleground Bengal’; the recent attack on the NIA team at Bhupatinagar in West Bengal’s East Midnapore district shows that the authorities are not dealing with the miscreants with an iron hand. And the lack of action emboldens anti-social elements to attack officials of agencies like the NIA. The state politicians are more concerned about securing their vote banks than the safety of the residents. Ahead of the Lok Sabha elections, it is important to ensure that there is no political interference in the functioning of the state police. Further, government agencies like the ED and the NIA must have no bias against any political outfit.

Rajinder Singh, Patiala

Ensure safety of tourists

Refer to the editorial ‘Safety protocol lax’; the death of Ritu Chopra, a seasoned paragliding pilot, has once again brought to light the lack of proper safety measures at Bir Billing, a popular destination for paragliding. Since the weather conditions in hilly areas are always unpredictable, there should be comprehensive regulations for the recruitment of pilots and safety guidelines to prevent mishaps. All illegal constructions in the area should be razed. The onus is on the authorities concerned to ensure that the adventures of tourists at Bir Billing do not take a tragic turn.

Harshita Kalra, Rajpura

Bar erring paragliding operators

Apropos of ‘Safety protocol lax’; the fact that even an experienced paragliding pilot could not save her life in the mishap is a commentary on the sorry state of affairs in Bir Billing. The difficult topography, coupled with unpredictable weather conditions, makes paragliding a lot more challenging in the terrain. The safety of the paragliders must remain the top priority for the local agencies. A strict enforcement of international standard operating procedures for paragliding should be the way forward. Besides, the authorities concerned should ensure that, in case of violation, the operator or agency is barred.

Bal Govind, Noida

Hate on campus

Six students from Afghanistan and one from East Africa were recently asked to vacate the Gujarat University’s hostel rooms for overstaying, in a move that came weeks after some foreign students were attacked for offering namaz on the premises. The incident could have been averted if tolerance and respect for other religions had been promoted on campus. It is common for Indians to express concern and sympathy for students from our country being discriminated against or targeted abroad. But how are we treating international students here at home? Religious tolerance is the need of the hour.

Lajwant Singh, by mail

Silence of AAP MPs

Refer to the report ‘Five AAP MPs keep mum on Kejri arrest, leaders baffled’; all MPs of a political party are bound to follow its agenda and promote its interests at the national level. The silence of these Rajya Sabha members amid the crisis being faced by the party has baffled AAP leaders and legislators. AAP is struggling to establish itself as a formidable political force at the national level, and the role of its MPs in helping achieve the objective cannot be overstated.

Jagdish Chander, Jalandhar

Scourge of defections

It has become increasingly common for political leaders to switch parties whenever they see any electoral benefit. It shows that today’s politicians are bereft of any ideology. Even big names in the political arena are not above hopping parties, and it proves that they have not worked at the ground level and lack a mass base. Besides, a lot of capable and educated people who are socially aware do not get to contest an election because of the huge sum of money required for a campaign. Even if there is a changing of the guard, power is generally transferred from one political bigwig to another. There is a need to have more people from a humble background in politics, as they would better understand the problems that the common man faces.

Rajesh Goyal, by mail

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit.

These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Apropos of the editorial ‘China’s LAC moves’; the current standoff with China remains a matter of serious concern. Beijing’s incursions into Ladakh and Doklam and the Dragon’s claim over Arunachal Pradesh make it abundantly clear that China wants to keep India on tenterhooks. Beijing plans to further pursue its policy of expansionism. It is noteworthy how China has reaped humongous profits through its trade relations with India over the years, but it never misses any opportunity to scuttle India’s impressive growth and stall its emergence as a leading global power. China’s intent to foment trouble along the LAC is obvious. The Dragon is bent on undermining India’s defence strategy in an invidious and calculated way without evincing any intent of waging a full-fledged conflict.

Roshan Lal Goel, Ladwa

Address root cause of illicit trade

With reference to the editorial ‘Kidney racket’; the cases of organ trafficking and exploitation of donors have become increasingly common. The widespread prevalence of the illicit trade points to the existence of an organised network involving several people, including health professionals. Such a trade cannot thrive without the patronage of political bigwigs and law enforcement officials. Therefore, while dealing with such cases, the role of powerful kingpins and their links should also be probed. The culprits should be dealt with strictly. Organ donors usually come from a poor background, which makes them vulnerable to exploitation. The trade cannot be reined in until the government addresses the root cause — poverty.

AG Rajmohan, Anantapur (AP)

Implement laws strictly

Refer to the editorial ‘Kidney racket’; organ trafficking continues unabated despite the legal restrictions on commercial dealings in them. According to a news report from 2016, roughly over 10,000 kidney transplants are performed illegally across the world. The practice remains rampant in India. In a lot of cases, forged documents are created for the donors to present them as relatives of the patient. The involvement of corporate hospitals in illegal transplants cannot be ruled out. Innocent and poor people are exploited by the agents, who pocket the lion’s share of the money. Collective efforts from governments, healthcare professionals and the public are needed to combat the unethical practice. Further, strict implementation of laws and raising awareness about the crime are crucial steps for protecting both donors and recipients from exploitation.

O Prasada Rao, Hyderabad

Chinese interference in polls

With reference to the report ‘China may use AI to influence poll in India, cautions Microsoft report’; the revelation made by Microsoft Threat Analysis Centre (MTAC) about China’s potential use of AI to sway elections is alarming. While such efforts in Taiwan proved ineffective, the mere possibility of interference in democracies like India is a cause for concern. The sophistication of AI-generated content poses a threat to the integrity of the electoral process. It is imperative that we bolster our cyber defences and raise public awareness to combat this new form of geopolitical manoeuvring. The resilience of our democratic institutions depends on our collective vigilance against such covert operations.

Gurdev Singh, Mohali

Spectre of AI manipulation

The ominous spectre of AI manipulation looms large over the democratic process, as Microsoft’s stark warning reveals China’s potential to subvert elections in India and the US. With geopolitical interests at stake, the tech giant’s cautionary note underscores the urgent need for vigilance. While past attempts in Taiwan and South Korea faltered, China’s relentless refinement of AI-generated content poses a grave threat. MTAC general manager Clint Watts’ insight into this perilous landscape serves as a wake-up call, highlighting the insidious tactics being employed by the Dragon. As elections approach, the integrity of our democratic institutions hangs in the balance. It is important that we fortify our defences against this digital onslaught and safeguard the sanctity of free and fair elections.

Gaganpreet Singh, Mohali

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

With reference to ‘Recalling the blood spilt on mountaintops’ (Nous Indica); as we approach the 25th anniversary of the Kargil conflict, it is crucial to reflect on the lessons learnt from the episode. The Kargil bloodshed, the Doklam incursion and the Ladakh standoff are stark reminders of the threats on our borders. These events should not be mere footnotes in history but pivotal moments for introspection and fortification. The valour of our soldiers must not be forgotten. However, the intelligence failure that necessitated such sacrifice should be looked into. There is a need to ensure that the bravery of our troops is matched by the vigil on our borders.

Gurpreet Kaur, Mohali

Prevent a repeat

Apropos of ‘Recalling the blood spilt on mountaintops’ (Nous Indica); the Kargil conflict is a saga of patriotism that is still fresh in the minds of Indians. The current standoff with China remains a matter of concern. The last thing we want is a repeat of the Kargil War. It would lead to bloodshed and the loss of lives all over again. China’s incursions into Ladakh and Doklam and the Dragon’s claim over Arunachal Pradesh expose Beijing’s nefarious ploy against India. New Delhi’s emphatic response to China’s baseless claims has shown that India will not succumb to such heavy-handed tactics.

Ravinder Singh, Jalandhar

Protecting India’s global image

With reference to the editorial ‘Tough stand on terror’; India needs to be wary of the Western powers that do not support New Delhi’s rise as a major power on the world stage. Of course, Western countries use India to counter the Chinese influence in the region. But when it comes to Indian efforts to nip the evil of terrorism in the bud, those powerful countries do nothing. West Asia is already going through a volatile phase. With hostilities between Iran and Israel reaching a flashpoint, the situation is a time bomb waiting to explode at any moment. India would do well to dispel the claims that R&AW carried out killings on Pakistani soil. In view of the recent diplomatic tensions between India and some Western powers, New Delhi cannot afford to take any step that will prompt the Western media to paint it as a country that does not respect other nations’ sovereignty.

Deepak Taak, Panchkula

Promise of a better future

Apropos of the editorial ‘Congress manifesto’; the Congress’ pledge to initiate affirmative action is a beacon of hope for India’s marginalised communities. For decades, these groups have been sidelined and their potential stifled by the archaic chains of caste. The proposed lifting of the reservation cap is not just a political promise. It is a clarion call for equality and justice. As the nation goes to the polls, the Congress’ commitment to the promises highlighted in its manifesto must become the cornerstone of governance, if it is voted to power. It’s time to dismantle the barriers of caste and craft a future where the circumstances of one’s birth do not decide one’s destiny.

Sargunpreet Kaur, Mohali

Don’t tinker with history

Refer to the news report ‘NCERT books drop references to Babri demolition, Gujarat riots’; the quick pace at which abrupt changes are being made to the curricula is not academically desirable. Introducing one drastic change after another in the syllabi does not bode well for the education system. In the field of science and technology, a periodic revision of the syllabi is necessary to keep pace with new inventions and discoveries. But there should be no unnecessary alterations in the books of literature or the social sciences. The NCERT must not play with history.

VK Anand, Chandigarh

NCERT book revisions welcome

With reference to ‘NCERT books drop references to Babri demolition, Gujarat riots’; the latest revisions made by the NCERT in the textbooks have sparked a debate about the portrayal of historical events and political narratives in educational material. Are these alterations an effort to reflect contemporary realities and correct factual errors in textbooks or just a needless syllabus revision? Some references to the Babri Masjid demolition have been dropped. The language is being changed to align with the latest developments in politics. There is a need to acknowledge the complexity of such events, ensuring that the communities affected are represented accurately. Overall, efforts to update textbooks reflect a commitment to providing students with accurate, relevant and inclusive learning material.

Shruti Saggar, Ludhiana

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit.

These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]

Refer to the editorial ‘Progressive guidelines’; the set of guidelines issued by the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India (CBCI) for all educational institutions under its jurisdiction is commendable. It will help promote diversity on the campus. The recitation of the Preamble to the Constitution and the setting up of an inter-religious prayer room will help inculcate patriotism and respect for all faiths among the students. Besides, in view of the communal atmosphere in the country, it is high time that all communities reviewed their religious practices and traditions. Discarding the divisive elements and promoting those that encourage harmony are imperative for helping children grow into mature adults. 

Subhash Vaid, New Delhi

Fostering an inclusive environment

Apropos of ‘Progressive guidelines’; the CBCI’s directive to educational institutions for the recitation of the Preamble and to respect all faiths is welcome. Avoiding the imposition of Christian traditions and setting up inter-faith prayer rooms demonstrate the CBCI’s commitment to diversity. Displaying the Preamble at the entrance of the institution promotes the values of justice, equality, liberty and fraternity. In a polarised society, prioritising individual dignity and national unity is vital for nurturing a sense of social responsibility among citizens. Other institutions affiliated with any religion should also emulate the CBCI’s model to foster an all-inclusive environment for the true development of the nation.

Chanchal S Mann, Una

Fostering a harmonious society

With reference to the editorial ‘Progressive guidelines’, the directive from the CBCI, urging schools under its jurisdiction to showcase constitutional values and respect all religions, is a step in the right direction. By emphasising justice, equality, liberty and fraternity on the campus, the body can foster a culture of inclusivity and tolerance. More such efforts should be made to help students grow into responsible citizens who create a harmonious society. Religion should be a source of solace for an individual, and hence, it should not be forced on anyone. The initiative reflects a commitment to nurturing responsible citizens and creating a more peaceful world.

Vijay Kumar Katial, Panchkula

Indian polls an internal affair

Apropos of the report ‘Don’t need UN to tell us poll should be free and fair: EAM’; External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar has rightly dismissed a senior UN official’s remarks on the conduct of elections in India. The UN Secretary-General must pull up the official concerned for overstepping his boundaries. The UN must stick to performing the functions it is supposed to. If the UN is so concerned about the integrity of elections, why did it not intervene when allegations of Russian interference in the 2016 US presidential elections were being made? Why did it not act when Chinese and Russian meddling in Canadian elections was suspected? People from other countries don’t need to lecture India about how elections should be held here.

Upendra Sharma, by mail

Double standards of US

Apropos of the report ‘Varying stance by US on arrest of Kejri, Imran’; it does not behove the US, the oldest democracy in the world and an ally of India, to treat the cases of Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal and former Pakistan PM Imran Khan differently. US State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller was caught in an awkward situation when asked why Washington supported imprisoned Kejriwal but not the hundreds of political prisoners in Pakistan, including Imran. Though he dismissed the characterisation, he failed to address the difference in the approach.

Vijaya Sharma, by mail

Curb wastage of food

It is concerning that at a time when 78.3 crore people are facing chronic hunger, 19 per cent of the food is getting wasted. The menace of food wastage needs to be checked. The global goal to halve it by 2030 is commendable, but a hidden enemy hinders progress. Current methods for tracking food waste are not adequate. We urgently need a multi-pronged approach to curb the issue. This includes robust measurement systems for identifying hotspots of wastage across the entire food supply chain.

Anansha Godani, Ujjain

Letters to the Editor, typed in double space, should not exceed the 200-word limit. These should be cogently written and can be sent by e-mail to: [email protected]