Defeat in victory: Dhumal, BJP’s CM face in Himachal, loses

Shimla, December 18

As the BJP in Himachal Pradesh celebrated its success in the hill state, one man looked crestfallen. For the party's chief ministerial candidate, Prem Kumar Dhumal, was among those defeated in the state that soundly voted for the saffron party.

Dhumal, 73, was expected to run the state if the BJP came to power. The BJP won, but the people voted against him.

(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

The former chief minister was defeated from Sujanpur by his Congress rival and former confidant Rajinder Rana.

He lost by 1,919 votes.

But the veteran BJP leader still wields considerable influence over the state, and it may be too early to write him off.

Dhumal accepted his defeat and said the result was unexpected and the party would do introspection

“Personal loss is not of much importance.The gain that victory has brought to state BJP is important. Thankful to people of the state for voting for BJP. In politics, sometimes one wins, sometimes one loses. I was not expecting to lose, I will do an analysis,” Dhumal was quoted as saying by ANI.

He congratulated the winners and party workers for the spectacular victory.

Meanwhile, Varinder Kanwar, who won from Kutlehar in Una district offered to vacate his seat for Dhumal.

Rajinder Rana termed his vitory as a symbol of people's confidence in the Congress.

“Thankful that they made me victorious. We have never stepped back from serving people in Sujanpur and we will always serve them,” Rana said.

Dhumal, who moved from farming to teaching English and then politics, is largely seen in the small peace-loving hill state as the common man's representative -- quite unlike his political rival and outgoing Congress chief minister 'Raja' Virbhadra Singh, who came from an erstwhile kingdom.

The gentle, soft-spoken and humble man from the lower hills has risen from the ranks in the BJP and was expected to become its chief minister for the third time.

He helmed the state earlier from March 1998 to March 2003, when he headed the BJP-Himachal Vikas Congress coalition government, and again from January 2008 to December 2012.

His supporters say Dhumal's amiable nature and easy availability are his USP.

An MA in English and a law graduate, he has been a three-time MP and a two-time Leader of the Opposition in the state Assembly.

Born into a non-political, farming family on April 10, 1944, in the Samirpur village of Hamirpur, the son of an ex-serviceman taught English in a private college before embracing politics.

Dhumal started his political career with the RSS students' wing, the ABVP. He became vice president of the Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha, the BJP's youth wing, in 1982.

The BJP picked him as its candidate for the Hamirpur Lok Sabha constituency in 1984 after state stalwart Jagdev Chand declined to contest from there. Dhumal lost the election, but won the seat in 1989 and 1991, before losing to Vikram Singh Katoch in 1996.

After the death of Jagdev Chand in 1993, Dhumal became active in state politics. He was BJP president in the state in 1993 and became its chief minister in March 1998 when he won the Bamsan constituency by a margin of 18,000 votes.

Often referred to as "sadak wale mukhya mantri" -- or the CM who built roads -- Dhumal was known for ushering in development, building up infrastructure such as a road network, the lifeline of the hill state.

He stepped down as an MLA in the Himachal Pradesh Legislative Assembly after winning the Hamirpur seat in a 2007 Lok Sabha byelection, held after the expulsion of the BJP's Suresh Chandel, who figured in the cash-for-questions scandal -- a controversy about MPs being bribed for asking questions in Parliament.

In another by-election -- this one in May 2008 -- Dhumal was replaced by his son, Thakur.

In the run-up to the polls, Dhumal, who became state chief minister for the second time in 2007, faced stiff competition from younger leaders eyeing the CM's chair.

But the veteran leader, who changed his constituency from Hamirpur this time, emerged as the front-runner once again.

In a break from tradition, BJP chief Amit Shah announced his name as the party's chief ministerial candidate a few days after launching its campaign in October this year.

Dhumal, however, is two years away from the 75-year upper age limit fixed by the BJP top brass for retirement from active politics.

The party seemingly chose him because he fitted into the state's caste combination. He is from the dominant Thakur community, comprising 28 per cent of the electorate.

His other competitors for the top slot included Shanta Kumar, who is in his 80s, and J P Nadda. Nadda, a Union minister, is 57, but belongs to the Brahmin community which comprises only 18 per cent of the electorate.

Some believed he might have lost the election because of the change in the constituency.

Dhumal and Singh have been alternating as chief ministers for the last two decades, as the state has seldom broken its tradition of electing the same government twice in a row.

While Dhumal is considered the strongman from the lower hills, Singh holds sway over the higher hills.

The Congress in the 2012 assembly elections won 36 seats with a 42.8 per cent vote share while the BJP won 26 seats with a 38.4 per cent vote share. — Agencies